Quick Columbus IN MLS Search

Browse All Columbus IN Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$425,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 21981034 MLS
"The wait is over! Schedule your showing today & get a first look at the latest masterpiece from Homes by Keeno! This historic beauty has new life & is ready to welcome the next owners! Downtown parking isn't an issue at this location, zip right in to your private parking area or use the brand new 2 car garage! You will notice right away that even though this home is 120+ years old, it has all the modern day updates! All new electrical, plumbing and HVAC are just the start; roof, gutters, siding, windows, concrete work, lighting, kitchen, flooring, custom bathrooms, LED lighting & more...make sure to ask your agent for the Updates List & fence plans to see everything that was completed in the down-to-the-studs remodel! Up the steps of the new front porch will lead you into the cozy family room. You'll swoon over the black brick fireplace with granite hearth and arched glass doors. Settle in for a good book in the den, this flex space has so much potential for work-from-home needs & the best natural light in the house! Close out the distractions by shutting the elegant curved original wood doors. Take a minute to appreciate the meticulously refinished main floor millwork, 1895 trim & doors never looked so good! Yeah, it's original! Move into the dining room where dinner parties await! Serve your guests next to an original built in sideboard that doubles as an adorable window seat. Peep the light fixture in the dining room before moving into the kitchen, it's perfection! Cool obsidian granite anchors the kitchen features to the theme of the home. So much storage space & windows in all the right places. Stainless appliances & workstation sink. 2 spacious bedrooms & a full bath w/rainfall shower & jetted tub are tucked away on the main level with just the right amount of privacy. The finished lower level offers 2 additional bedrooms & a custom tiled shower in the full bath, as well as laundry, storage & a massive living space. The possibilities are endless!

1637 Washington Street, Columbus

$425,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21981634 MLS
Charming 3-Bedroom Home in Coveted Tipton Lakes Neighborhood Welcome to your dream home located in the highly sought-after Tipton Lakes neighborhood, nestled on tranquil Butternut Pond. This beautiful 3-bedroom, 2.5-bathroom residence offers a perfect blend of elegance, comfort, and natural beauty. The expansive backyard is a peaceful retreat, featuring mature trees and lush landscaping that seamlessly blend into the picturesque backdrop of Butternut Pond. Enjoy the soothing sounds of nature and breathtaking views year-round. Two entrances lead to an inviting upper deck, perfect for morning coffee or evening relaxation while overlooking the serene pond. The finished basement is a versatile space ideal for a family room or entertainment area. It features walk-out French doors that open to a covered patio, extending your living space and providing a seamless indoor-outdoor experience. Stay comfortable year-round with energy-efficient geothermal heating, ensuring your home is cozy and environmentally friendly. This home is more than just a place to live-it's a lifestyle. Enjoy access to the Tipton Lakes amenities, including walking trails, community events, and marina. With its prime location, stunning views, and modern comforts, this Tipton Lakes gem is a rare find. Don't miss the opportunity to make this serene and elegant home yours. Schedule a viewing today and experience the best of Tipton Lakes living!

1071 Butternut Drive, Columbus

$400,000
21979125 MLS
Experience the epitome of lakeside living with this exceptional lot boasting 100 feet of mesmerizing lakefront on Grandview Lake. Nestled in a serene location, this property offers an ideal retreat for those seeking tranquility, natural beauty, and countless recreational opportunities. Step onto a grand dock, spacious enough to accommodate multiple watercraft, complete with a boat lift that ensures convenient and secure docking and a meticulously crafted concrete sea wall, providing not only a protective barrier but also a striking feature that effortlessly blends with the surrounding landscape. Need storage for all your lake toys and equipment? Look no further! This lot includes an expansive shed, thoughtfully designed with practicality, functionality and lined with antique wood from Camp Atterbury. With power supply readily available, it offers endless possibilities-whether you envision it as additional storage space or as a custom workshop. Picture yourself on a peaceful evening, gathered around a cozy fire pit, its warm glow casting a magical ambiance as you relish captivating lake views. From roasting marshmallows to sharing stories, this space is destined to create cherished memories with loved ones. With this lot on Grandview Lake, the choice is yours. Embrace the property as it stands, a serene haven ready to be enjoyed, or unleash your creativity and build your dream home, custom-tailored to your desires. The possibilities are endless, and the canvas awaits your imagination. Seize this opportunity to own a slice of lakeside paradise, where endless adventures, breathtaking views, and cherished memories become a part of your everyday life. Don't miss out-make this Grandview Lake lot your ultimate retreat. Schedule your showing now.

11954 W Glen Lane, Columbus

$474,900
5 Beds 3 Baths 21981044 MLS
Welcome to 2834 Buttercup Ct W located in the coveted Wildflower Estates neighborhood and Southside School district. Custom built by Phillips Development with quality materials/finishes thru-out. This spacious 5 bed 2.5 bath home is situated on a large corner lot with a privacy fenced backyard. Covered front porch area. Once inside you will be greeted with an abundance of natural light and the open floor plan. Large living room with new hardwood flooring. Spacious gourmet kitchen features a center island with breakfast bar and an abundance of counter space and custom Amish cabinetry, Stainless steel appliances and granite countertops. Breakfast room off the kitchen. Formal dining room area as well. Main level Primary suite with cathedral ceilings and en suite bath with double sinks, tiled walk-in shower, soaking tub and walk-in closet. Laundry room is conveniently located on the main level . Upstairs features a loft/sitting area and 4 spacious bedrooms all with walk-in closets. The large 20x16 5th bedroom could also be used as an additional living space/family room. The full unfinished basement with 9+ foot ceilings provides lots of extra space to spread out and the potential to finish as you wish. Basement includes a large Rec room, exercise area, and storage room and also features rough in plumbing for additional bathroom and egress window. Outside in the backyard you will enjoy a beautiful space for entertaining and relaxation with the covered back deck/patio area and pergola as well as vinyl privacy fence with lifetime transferable warranty. 3 car finished garage. Some recent updates include vinyl fence, High efficiency HVAC 2022 with 10 year warranty, hardwood flooring, irrigation system, pergola, etc... Don't miss out on obtaining everything this home has to offer!

2834 Buttercup Court W, Columbus

$485,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 21971662 MLS
This stunning ranch home located in Wildflower Estates is the dream home you have been waiting for. The gorgeous hardwood floors, soaring ceilings and exquisite millwork, welcome you into the foyer and invite you to spend time in the living and dining rooms. The kitchen features granite countertops, walk-in pantry and adjoining breakfast room. The kitchen and breakfast room flow seamlessly into the hearth room with vaulted ceiling and full stone surround fireplace, making for a cozy family retreat. On the other side of the main living space are three main level bedrooms, providing separation and privacy. The primary bedroom has a beautiful tray ceiling and adjoining luxurious master bath with separate his and her sinks, full shower, whirlpool tub and walk-in closet. The two additional spacious bedrooms adjoin a shared Jack and Jill bathroom. Completing the main level you will find an additional half bath, full laundry room with storage cabinets, laundry sink, and dry bar / family command center. Not to be missed, the finished basement includes an additional huge family room, large bedroom, full bath and ample storage space. The unfinished bonus space in the basement could be utilized in any number of ways to meet your needs. All this with a fully fenced back yard, that includes a covered porch and raised paver patio, is perfect for entertaining. Fresh paint in living area, new carpet in main level bedrooms, new tankless hot water heater, new battery for backup sump pump and irrigation system. This thoughtfully designed home is a rare find and a must-see.

2812 Sunflower Court, Columbus

$415,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 21964436 MLS
Welcome to your dream opportunity at 5944 Bellsville Pike - where history, modern amenities, and unlimited potential converge in this unique property, nestled on just over 5 acres of lush greenery. Perfectly positioned for those who envision a blend of residential tranquility and entrepreneurial spirit, this house is not just a home; it's a gateway to endless possibilities. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by the warmth and charm of a lovingly updated interior. With 3 cozy bedrooms and 2 modern bathrooms, comfort is at the forefront of this residence. The house boasts an array of recent upgrades ensuring peace of mind for its new owners - from electrical systems brought up to today's standards, a new sump pump, and a presby septic system designed for optimum efficiency, to the essential comforts of a new AC unit and a newer furnace keeping the seasons at bay. But wait, there's more - the property comes equipped with 3 outbuildings that open up a world of opportunity. The historic Crouch's Market stands as a testament to the land's rich heritage, also enjoying General Business zoning alongside the large barn on premises. Whether you're dreaming of launching your own short-term rental endeavor or crafting a unique retreat that blends commercial vibrancy with rural serenity, this property offers the canvas. With no parking space limitations to curb your ambitions or guest visits, every inch of its sprawling expanse invites you to explore, create, and transform. Embrace the blend of history, modernity, and potential at 5944 Bellsville Pike - where your vision can take root and flourish.

5944 Bellsville Pike, Columbus

Start Your Search

IDX information is provided by the Indiana Regional MLS and is exclusively for the consumers' personal, non-commercial use and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Data is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed accurate by the MLS.

Last updated


IDX information provided by the Indiana Regional MLS

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2024 Metropolitan Indianapolis Board of REALTORS®

Between $400K - $500K Columbus Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Columbus and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!