Quick Columbus IN MLS Search

Browse All Columbus IN Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

$499,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 22124440 MLS
Stunning midcentury modern home on Columbus' near north side. This house is a full custom renovation and must be seen in person. The recessed living room is a nod to the "conversation pit" made famous to by The Miller House and features huge windows with motorized blinds. Along with the skylights, the clean, white finishes create a vibrant, modern, calming space that is just so inviting. Custom walnut cabinetry throughout the main living area and kitchen include built- in collapsible steps for reaching the uppers; a full coffee and spirits bar with custom pull- out shelving off the dining room; walnut bookcases and vertical slats that contrast beautifully with the light colors. Large- scale tile flooring throughout the home are modern and so easy to clean. The bathrooms are loaded with custom finishes and special features, including a stand alone tub in the master, steam shower and heated floors in the secondary bathroom. Master ensuite with large walk- in closet is set apart from the rest of the house, offering a private and comfortable retreat. The basement invites you in to relax in front of a gas log fireplace, is plumbed for a wet bar, and has another full bathroom. The south side of the house features three generous bedrooms, the secondary bath, and a small play room for artistic expression. The home is protected from the elements by a membrane roof, a vapor barrier in the crawlspace, and spray foam insulation in the exterior walls. Even the meticulously tidy electrical panel and plumbing manifold must be seen to be believed. The home's location is incredibly convenient, within easy walking distance to schools K-12, a wonderful cafe, restaurants, and grocery store. The owners are even leaving behind their robot lawn mower! This is a truly stunning home that offers so much quality and peace of mind to its next owners. Isn't that what you're looking for?

2585 Chestnut Street, Columbus

$464,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 22121080 MLS
Welcome to this beautiful all-brick ranch in highly desirable Tipton Lakes, thoughtfully designed with space, comfort, and effortless everyday living in mind. A welcoming covered front porch leads into a bright, inviting interior featuring abundant natural light and impressive 10-foot ceilings. The home offers four bedrooms, three full baths, a formal dining room, and a dedicated home office, providing plenty of flexibility for both everyday living and entertaining. The kitchen features maple cabinetry, quartz countertops, and an abundance of storage and prep space, while hardwood floors add timeless warmth and character throughout the main living areas. The gas-log fireplace creates a cozy gathering spot on crisp fall evenings, while the covered rear porch offers the perfect place to enjoy morning coffee or unwind with friends. The finished lower level adds valuable living space and includes a fourth bedroom, full bath, dedicated office space, and generous storage. Fresh paint and new carpet make the lower level feel bright, comfortable, and inviting. Concrete safe room in basement. Beyond the home, enjoy all that Tipton Lakes has to offer, including miles of paved walking trails, pickleball courts, a marina, beach and lake privileges, and a variety of community events. This exceptional home combines comfortable ranch style living, thoughtful updates, and an incredible neighborhood lifestyle-all in one beautiful package.

6055 Boulder Court, Columbus

$489,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 22121275 MLS
RARE FIND- Waterfront property located on Heron Cove in Tipton Lakes. This is the one you've been waiting for! This beautifully updated 4-bedroom, 3-bathroom home is perfectly positioned on a prime waterfront lot on a very quiet street, offering privacy, charm, and a fantastic location just moments from the heart of downtown Columbus. Easy access to 65. As you step inside, you're greeted by a bright, open layout featuring gorgeous almost-new light and bright carpeting and luxury vinyl tile flooring that flows seamlessly throughout the entire main level of this home. The spacious living area invites you to relax and entertain with ease, creating the perfect setting for gatherings with family and friends. Moving into the kitchen, you'll find a modern, updated space equipped with sleek newer stainless-steel appliances, abundant counter space, granite countertops, huge center island, pantry and a layout designed for both everyday living and effortless hosting. The split-bedroom floor plan provides comfort and privacy for everyone. The main-level primary suite is a true retreat, featuring generous space with an outstanding waterfront view and an oversized walk-in closet that delivers both convenience and a touch of everyday luxury. Master bathroom has double sinks, whirlpool tub and separate shower. The additional bedrooms are well-sized and versatile, ideal for guests, a home office and growing families! Step outside and enjoy the benefits of your wide-open waterfront property that offers privacy and space, perfect for outdoor living, or future entertaining with a large, covered deck. Schedule your private showing today before this one is gone! Home is being sold "As Is".

6134 Pelican Lane, Columbus

$439,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 22121048 MLS
Timeless Country Charm Meets Modern Comfort on 3.06 Acres Step into 126 years of history with this classic white farmhouse, perfectly situated on 3.06 scenic acres surrounded by farmland. Offering the ultimate blend of peaceful rural living and modern convenience close to town, schools, shopping and restaurants. This 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home is packed with updates while preserving its authentic warmth. House Highlights Primary Suite: Conveniently located downstairs, featuring original hardwood floors, a massive walk-in closet, and a private ensuite bath. Fresh & Turn-Key: Brand-new vinyl plank flooring flows throughout the rest of the home, complemented by fresh, crisp paint from top to bottom. Sunlit Kitchen & Enclosed Porch: The charming kitchen overlooks the sweeping, tree-lined backyard. Step right out into the enclosed back porch-the ultimate cozy spot for your morning coffee or evening meals. Updated Baths: Beautifully updated half-bath on the main level and a full updated bath upstairs to serve the additional bedrooms. Peace of Mind Upgrades Brand-New Roof & Gutters on the house, plus a brand-new roof on the detached garage. Brand-New Tempstar Central A/C to keep you cool all summer. Best of Both Worlds Utilities: Connected to city water for household use, with outdoor spigots hooked up to the well for easy, low-cost yard care. Outbuildings & Land The property itself offers open green space, magnificent mature shade trees, and exceptional outbuildings: Massive 3-Car Detached Garage: Ideal for vehicles, equipment, or a dream workshop. Powered Shed: Located right behind the garage, equipped with electricity and ready to be finished into a home office, guest space, studio, or craft room. Historic Barn: Situated at the back of the property with both electric and water connected-just needs a little TLC to bring it back to its full glory!

5365 E State Street E, Columbus

$460,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 22120738 MLS
Room to breathe, space to spread out, and Brown County beauty right in your backyard! Located in beautiful Brown County with a Columbus address, this well-maintained 2018 ranch sits on 6.47 acres and offers just over 1,800 square feet of comfortable one-level living. A peaceful wooded backdrop and a setting that's hard to beat. The bright, open floor plan features impressive 12-foot raised ceilings that make the main living area feel spacious and inviting. The kitchen is right at the heart of the home with stainless steel appliances, a large center island with breakfast bar, plenty of workspace, and an easy flow into the dining and living areas-perfect for everyday living or having friends over. The split-bedroom floor plan offers added privacy, with the primary suite tucked away from the additional bedrooms. The primary features its own private bath with double sinks and a walk-in closet, while the additional bedrooms offer flexibility for guests, a home office, or hobbies. One of the best spots in the house is the glassed-in porch, perfect for morning coffee, relaxing with a good book, or simply enjoying the peaceful surroundings and changing seasons. Just outside, the open patio offers even more space for grilling and entertaining. Need room for vehicles, equipment, or a workshop? In addition to the 2-car attached garage, there's a separate 2-car detached garage plus a barn, giving you plenty of options for storage, hobbies, lawn equipment, or recreational toys. With 6.47 acres, newer construction, a great one-level layout, multiple garages, a barn, and the National Forest as your neighbor, this property offers a combination that's not easy to find. If you've been looking for privacy, peaceful surroundings, and room to enjoy the outdoors, this one is definitely worth seeing in person. There's plenty of room here to enjoy an easier pace while still having the convenience of its Columbus address!

7099 S State Road 135, Columbus

$420,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 202521054 MLS
One-Level, Low-Maintenance Living in Desirable Tipton Lakes! Enjoy the ease of single-level living in this beautifully maintained, handicap-accessible home, ideally located on a quiet cul-de-sac in Tipton Lakes—a meticulously cared-for neighborhood with walking trails, a private backyard setting, and close proximity to the Tipton Lakes Marina. Surrounded by mature trees and lush landscaping, this home offers comfort, convenience, and a peaceful environment. Step into a welcoming, light-filled foyer that opens to a spacious great room with direct access to a charming screened-in porch—the perfect place to enjoy your morning coffee or relax in the evening. The generous primary suite features double vanities, a walk-in shower, a large walk-in closet, and abundant natural light. The second bedroom includes an en-suite bath, ideal for guests. Additional highlights include a dedicated office, a bright and sunny kitchen with a cozy breakfast nook, and a walk-out patio just off the screened porch. The oversized two-car garage offers built-in cabinetry and a separate storage area for added functionality. Notable Updates: A new HVAC system installed in early July 2025. The following improvements were noted in a previous listing and have not been independently verified by the estate: 2018: New exterior door for screened porch 2017: New windows and door in the great room; new windows in the primary bedroom and bath; screened porch re-screened and painted 2016: New A/C unit 2012: New roof Buyers may conduct inspections; however, please note that this is an estate sale. Schedule your private showing today and discover the comfort and lifestyle Tipton Lakes has to offer!

1220 Pintail Ct, Columbus

$430,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 22114690 MLS
Summer is not over yet, there is still time to enjoy swimming in your heated in-ground saltwater pool! This classic 5BR, 3BA home in Riverview Acres is an entertainer's dream, with a private backyard oasis that will be the envy of your friends and family. Enjoy 300 sqft of deck space right off of your sunroom perfect for a gas grill and smoker, plus plenty of space to add a hot tub or sauna. Paver patio area offers cedar gazebo with outdoor lighting. Designated play area with wood swingset could easily be transformed into a garden space if so desired. The interior of the home offers timeless finishes paired with many modern updates. Traditional floorplan with formal living room and dining room both with luxury vinyl plank flooring. Kitchen offers bright white cabinets adorned with premium granite countertops and tile backsplash. Main level bedroom and full bathroom with tile walk-in shower stall. Upstairs you will find 3/4" solid hardwood flooring throughout the four bedrooms. Shared full bath with double vanities and tub with tile shower surround. Full basement is finished offering large rec room, bonus room, utility room, and full bath with corner shower. Expansive driveway space can accomodate large gatherings and the 2 car attached garage is fully finished offering epoxy coating on floor. Your new home is conveniently located near Parkside Elementary School, with a short walk to the park and trail. If you are looking for an established neighborhood with NO HOA restrictions, this just may be "THE ONE"!

4206 Ridgeway Avenue, Columbus

$440,000
4 Beds 4 Baths 22104341 MLS
Located in the highly sought-after Oakbrook enclave of Tipton Lakes, this spacious 4-bedroom home offers a functional layout, abundant natural light, and exceptional living space designed for both everyday comfort and entertaining with a large wooded backyard. Featuring an abundance of windows on both the main and upper levels, the open-concept floor plan creates a bright and welcoming atmosphere throughout.The main level showcases hardwood flooring in the living room, dining room, family room, and breakfast area, complemented by ceramic tile flooring in the kitchen. Just off the entry, a dedicated flex room and formal dining room provide versatile spaces for a home office, study, or entertaining guests. The open family room flows seamlessly into the kitchen, the perfect setup for modern living. Ample storage is thoughtfully integrated throughout the home.Upstairs, you'll find four generously sized bedrooms, including a spacious primary suite featuring a walk-in closet and a private ensuite bath with dual vanities, soaking tub, and separate shower.The partial finished lower level significantly expands the living space with a large family room featuring an egress window, room complete with a closet and private ensuite bath, ideal for guests, multigenerational living, or a private retreat. A dedicated storage and utility room adds even more functional space. Additional updates include a tankless water heater for improved energy efficiency, rebuilt chimney for the fireplace and a brand-new roof installed in May 2026. Newer HVAC, Chimney rebuilt in 2015.Updated kitchen, counter depth Refrigerator. Immediate possession.

6064 Acorn Drive, Columbus

$429,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 22104337 MLS
Discover the perfect blend of country living and modern convenience in this beautiful farmhouse-style home situated on a private 4.45-acre partially wooded lot. Offering 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and flexible living spaces, this property is ideal for those seeking acreage, equestrian amenities, and room to grow. The spacious kitchen features abundant cabinetry and countertop space, making it perfect for everyday living and entertaining. Multiple living areas, including a cozy lower-level family room, provide plenty of room for gatherings and relaxation. A versatile main-level bonus room with walk-out access can serve as a home office, hobby room, guest suite, or potential fifth bedroom. Step outside to your own backyard retreat featuring an oversized deck overlooking a beautifully landscaped in-ground swimming pool. The pool house provides convenient storage for equipment and outdoor essentials, while the expansive yard offers endless opportunities for recreation and outdoor enjoyment.Outdoor enthusiasts and hobby farmers will appreciate the properties exceptional amenities, including two large detached barns, horse stalls, a chicken pen, fenced area, hay pasture, pond, creek, vegetable garden, flower garden and newly planted fruit trees."The attached two-car garage adds convenience and additional storage. Located just minutes from Interstate 65, shopping, dining, and everyday conveniences, this rare acreage property combines functionality and accessibility. Whether you're searching for a horse property, hobby farm, multi-generational living opportunity, or a private country retreat, this exceptional home offers it all.

5998 W 550 S, Columbus

$435,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 22106644 MLS
COME EXPERIENCE EASY LIVING AT THE VILLAS OF STONECREST! This stunning all-brick home is located in an exclusive 55+ gated community, designed for comfort, convenience, and carefree living. One-level living with no steps, wide hallways and doors, and an open concept layout across 2,000 sq ft makes this home both accessible and inviting. You'll love the spacious rooms, high ceilings, and abundant windows in this highly desired end unit with large side lawn. The stainless steel applianced Kitchen with a breakfast bar offers a separate pantry, abundant cabinet storage and granite counter space, overlooking the Dining Room and Living Room, perfect for entertaining. Sun room off the living room for extra seating, reading, or office connects to rear patio. The Primary Suite features a large shower, double sinks, dual walk-in closets with built-ins. Two more Bedrooms, and additional spacious bath, offer flexibility for hosting visitors, hobbies, or working from home. Extra storage is easy with pull-down attic stairs in the oversized, 2 car garage. Laundry Room with sink and abundance of cabinets for ultimate convenience. Community amenities include a large clubhouse, pool, and beautifully maintained grounds. Plus, lawn care and snow removal are included - making every day feel like a vacation! Updates in include top-down/bottom-up blinds throughout, HVAC, paint, water softener, washer/dryer, range and microwave, shower head in Primary Bath, Touch activated Kitchen faucet. Don't miss out - schedule your private showing today!

5176 Marco Drive, Columbus

$499,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 22103435 MLS
Welcome to 2316 Lafayette Avenue! Beautifully updated from top to bottom, this 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath home offers the perfect blend of timeless charm, character, and modern amenities. Gorgeous hardwood floors flow throughout much of the home, creating a warm and inviting feel from the moment you step inside. The spacious living room features a cozy gas-log fireplace and two built-in workstations, ideal for working from home or homework space. The dining room showcases custom built-ins and opens beautifully to the dream kitchen, complete with a large center island, double oven, butler's pantry, abundant custom storage, and updated appliances throughout. The main-level primary suite features custom closets and a beautifully updated en suite bath. A convenient drop zone with built-in storage cubbies adds everyday functionality. Upstairs, wide stairs lead to three large bedrooms and a second beautifully updated custom bath. Additional built-ins, a cedar closet, and walk-in attic access provide outstanding storage options. The finished basement offers even more living space with a family room, office, and laundry/storage area. Dual-control HVAC offers year-round comfort. Step outside to enjoy the heated pool with automatic cover, perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Located just one block from Donner Park, this completely renovated home delivers the charm of an older home with the comfort and convenience of today's modern updates. Immediate possession available!

2316 Lafayette Avenue, Columbus

Start Your Search

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


Between $400K - $500K Columbus Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Columbus and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!