Between $500,000 - $600,000 Trafalgar IN Real Estate, Homes, Condos for Sale

Enjoy the perfect combination of privacy, space and modern updates in this spacious 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home with a walk-out basement. Situated on 1.5 acres in a secluded setting with only one neighboring home, this home offers the peaceful lifestyle you've been looking for, providing space to relax or entertain. Major renovations completed approximately 11 years ago included updates to the electrical, plumbing, HVAC, flooring, siding, gutters, and roof. Recent improvements include a stunning 14' x 50' upper deck (2021), a concrete lower patio, fresh paint on both the house and barn (2024), and new landscaping with edging and rock (2025). The detached garage has been enhanced with skinned and insulated walls and ceilings, making it ideal for a workshop, storage, hobbies, or additional workspace. Blown-in insulation has also been added to both the home and barn for improved energy efficiency. With ample living space, extensive updates, and a private setting, this property is ready to welcome its next owner. Schedule your showing today!

4012 W State Road 135, Trafalgar

$575,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22096429 MLS

RARE HOME & PROPERTY IN SOUTHERN JOHNSON COUNTY! 4 BEDROOM, 2 1/2 BATH ALL BRICK RANCH ON 5.23 ACRES in TRAFALGAR, INDIAN CREEK SCHOOLS! This home has good bones; just needs some updating! It boast over 2,400 square feet, a 1,020 square foot unfinished basement, large 2 car garage, 30'x40' - 3 bay POLE BARN with 10' ceilings and concrete floor; and approximately an acre of nicely fenced pasture. The HVAC and HOT WATER HEATER are only 6 MONTHS! Septic was updated in 2019. On city water, but there is a well on-site. The property is quiet and surrounded mostly by woods. Five minutes to Apple Works and Betley Woods at Glacier's End Trail, 10 minutes to IC Schools, 20 minutes to I-65; 30 minutes to Columbus, Nashville and Brown County State Park; 55 minutes to downtown Indy!

1546 W 750 S, Trafalgar

$599,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22095475 MLS

NEW PRICE + $7,000 in Buyer allowable expenses! Use this to buy down your rate, aid in closing costs, & more! Tucked away on 5 scenic wooded acres in the rolling hills of Brown County, this beautifully updated retreat offers more than a home-it offers a lifestyle. With over 2,600 square feet, 4 bedrooms, 3 full baths, and flexible living spaces, this property blends privacy, comfort, and connection to nature. Step inside to soaring ceilings and a light-filled living room with floor-to-ceiling windows that invite the outdoors in. The open layout flows into a spacious kitchen with stainless steel appliances, abundant cabinetry, and an oversized pantry-perfect for prepping, gathering, and/or entertaining. Recent upgrades elevate both style and peace of mind, including new main-level flooring, fresh interior paint, new roof, and a dual-zone climate system with energy-efficient mini splits for year-round comfort. The main-level primary suite offers a peaceful retreat with an ensuite bath and direct access to a four-season sunroom-ideal for morning coffee or unwinding at sunset. Upstairs provides additional bedrooms, full bath, loft space, and room to adapt to your needs. Outside is where this property truly becomes a dream. Explore private wooded trails, relax on expansive decks, or enjoy incredible deer activity-whether you're an avid hunter or simply appreciate the beauty of wildlife right outside your door. All of this, just minutes from Indian Creek Schools, the charm of downtown Nashville, and an easy drive to nearby amenities. If you've been searching for more than a home-something peaceful, private, and unforgettable-this is your opportunity.

7811 Bean Blossom Road, Trafalgar

$535,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22063530 MLS

Beautiful Custom all brick ranch nestled in the woods and backing up to 912 Acres of Atterbury Fish & Wildlife land! Private drive leads you to this hidden paradise. Great room is huge with raised ceiling & a gas fireplace flanked by built-in bookshelves. Solid honey oak flooring throughout the home & Pella Windows w/Blt-in blinds give you the custom home feel. Kitchen has tons of cabinets, new over & microwave and tons of counter space. And down miss the 8x5 walk-In Pantry. Primary suite with vaulted ceiling and fireplace. Primary bathroom is large & has jetted tub & large walk-in shower & skylight. Primary walk-in closet has access to the laundry room. Front bedroom would also make great office. The other 2 bedrooms & full bath are on the other side of the house. Sun room has 2 full walls of windows to enjoy the beautiful setting or to observe the wildlife. Exterior has a wonderful, stamped patio with a Royal Spa hot tub (included)and a built-in Grill with a hard-line gas line. Home has a 26x24 attached garage with a 16x6 separate storage area (new garage door 2023) and then a 36x24 Detached garage. The northside of the property butts up to a private pond. Improvements: HVAC 2019 Evolution System, Exterior paint 2023, Wtr. Htr 5yr, Wtr. Softener 7yr, all recessed lights are LED. Enjoy the peace and quiet of nature from your backyard where deer roam on the property as your backyard neighbor is the Atterbury wildlife area. This home has built with no transitions on the flooring and 36" doors for handicap accessibility as well.

6799 S Nineveh Road, Trafalgar

$525,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22062402 MLS

Imagine living at 3660 S 25 W in Trafalgar, IN where classic farmhouse meets industrial charm. Nestled on 2.5 acres in Trafalgar is a beautiful 3 BR, 3 BA home that is one of a kind. The abundance of windows allows natural light into almost every part of the home. On the main level is the master bedroom and bathroom, family room, dining room, kitchen, laundry room, an office/playroom and a large 12x4 closet that is used for a pantry and coat closet. The second full bathroom is also on the main level and has a walk in shower. The upstairs has 2 bedrooms, a full bathroom with a tub and a loft area that is currently being used for a small office space. There is new premium waterproof flooring that was just installed this year in some areas of the house. Fresh paint in some rooms as well as some new light fixtures. The entire house has been spray foamed. Enjoy the peace and quiet while sitting on the 15x9 screened in porch. Looking for a large pole barn? This property has that too. This 40x50 pole barn has water, electricity and a large wood burning stove that has a 45in x24 in firebox that allows for heating in the colder months and is insulated! Perfect place for a work shop, extra storage and entertaining. The 2 car detached garage is also a space that offers plenty of room for your vehicles and extra space for storage. Fully fenced 1/4 acre pasture and a chicken coop are just a few more features to make this property stand out. Only 5 min to Indian Creek Schools and 12 minutes to downtown Franklin. Don't miss your chance to own this charming gem in Trafalgar. Finished sq ft is 2316. Other information reflects unfinished basement.

3660 S 25 W, Trafalgar

$540,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22060674 MLS

Ready for a unique opportunity to embrace refined rural living? The heart of this home resides in its thoughtfully designed kitchen, a culinary dream featuring shaker cabinets that complement the stone countertops, while a large kitchen island provides ample space for meal preparation and casual dining, all accentuated by a stylish backsplash and a range hood. The bathrooms offer a spa-like experience, with tiled walk-in showers and double vanities, creating a serene and functional space. The living room is defined by a vaulted ceiling, adding a sense of grandeur and airiness to the space, making it perfect for both relaxing evenings and sophisticated entertaining. One of the bedrooms features crown molding, adding a touch of architectural elegance and character to this personal space. Two primary suites both with beautiful views of country landscape. Outside, a private pool with new pump offers a refreshing escape during warm days, while the deck and outdoor dining area create the perfect setting for al fresco meals and social gatherings, set against the backdrop of a peaceful rural area. A porch provides a welcoming entrance and a place to relax and enjoy the surroundings, while a walk-in closet offers generous storage space. Many updates including front door 2023, concrete walk and front steps 2023, A/C 2025, cellar/crawl encapsulation along with new sump pump. New oak stairs with wrought iron railing. Tankless water heater. additional hot water heater in cellar not in use. 40x40 pole barn with electricity and built in loft for storage. 3rd bdrm used as office. 1930 residence had an added wing in 2017 including laundry room, primary bedroom and oversized 2 car garage with plenty of storage. 3 bedrooms and 3 full bathrooms within approximately 3200 square feet across two stories, is more than just a home; it's a lifestyle defined by comfort, and the tranquility of a rural setting. Sunrises from the front porch and gorgeous sunsets from pool deck and fire pit

7078 S 125 W, Trafalgar

$505,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202530267 MLS

Wonderful, spacious full brick ranch on beautiful Mystic Lake! Covered front porch, separate back porch & back patio overlooking lake, backyard & firepit. Primary BR w/full private bath, separate commode room, double sinks, tub, shower, walk-in closet, and door opening to low maintenance back deck and lake. BR2 also has a private full bath & walk-in closet. Great Room w/cozy gas fireplace & cathedral ceiling. Family room w/full wall of windows overlooking backyard & lake! Roomy laundry room & bonus room or office for whatever your needs may be. Separate Dining Room w/closet for a pantry, lots of cabinets & counters in kitchen and breakfast bar. Solid wood doors & trim. Long tree-lined concrete driveway with lots of parking and turnaround. Freshly painted interior, carpets recently professionally cleaned. New furnace & A/C to be installed 8/4/2025. Clean & ready to move in and make it your own! Located in Indian Creek School District just 6 minutes to Trafalgar, 20 minutes to the fun in Nashville, 20 minutes to Kroger, 30 minutes to Greenwood Mall, 45 minutes to the Indy Airport, & 50 minutes to a Colts Game!

6063 W State Road 135, Trafalgar

$505,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22053823 MLS

Wonderful, spacious full brick ranch on beautiful Mystic Lake on 5.5 acres! Covered front porch, separate back porch & back patio overlooking lake, backyard & firepit. Primary BR w/full private bath, separate commode room, double sinks, tub, shower, walk-in closet, and door opening to low maintenance back deck and lake. BR2 also has a private full bath & walk-in closet. Great Room w/cozy gas fireplace & cathedral ceiling. Family room w/full wall of windows overlooking backyard & lake! Roomy laundry room & bonus room or office for whatever your needs may be. Separate Dining Room w/closet for a pantry, lots of cabinets & counters in kitchen and breakfast bar. Solid wood doors & trim. Long tree-lined concrete driveway with lots of parking and turnaround. Freshly painted interior, carpets recently professionally cleaned. New furnace & A/C installed 8/12/2025. Clean & ready to move in and make it your own! Located in Indian Creek School District just 6 minutes to Trafalgar, 20 minutes to the fun in Nashville, 20 minutes to Kroger, 30 minutes to Greenwood Mall, 45 minutes to the Indy Airport, & 50 minutes to a Colts Game!

6063 W State Road 135, Trafalgar

$585,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22033492 MLS

Nestled on 10.67 acres of picturesque countryside, this stunning and meticulously maintained retreat offers peace, privacy, and natural beauty. As you approach, a charming bridge welcomes you home, leading to a like-new 3-bedroom, 2-bath ranch that perfectly blends comfort and style. Step onto the full-length covered front porch, ideal for savoring morning coffee or unwinding as the sun sets. The side entry near the garage features a convenient mudroom-perfect for storing gear after a day outdoors. Inside, laminated hardwood floors provide both durability and elegance, while 9-foot ceilings with raised details in the main living area enhance the sense of spaciousness. The modern kitchen boasts a center island with barstool seating, a gas range, and a large pantry, making it a chef's dream. A wood-burning fireplace with blowers adds warmth and ambiance to the living room, while solar tubes fill the bathrooms with natural light. With a dual-fuel heat pump, this 2015-built home is as efficient as it is inviting. Beyond the home, the 56x32 deluxe pole barn offers ample space for vehicles, toys, and treasures. Featuring a large, conditioned workshop, half bath, separate 200-amp electrical service, and a covered porch and deck, this structure is the ultimate workspace and storage solution. A garden area and shed provide space for cultivating fresh produce, while a small livestock barn across the footbridge offers additional versatility. The property rises behind the home to a breathtaking elevated plateau, revealing meadows, mature trees, gorgeous views, and a wildlife pond-a perfect place to enjoy nature's serenity. Whether you're looking for a peaceful getaway, a hobby farm, or a luxurious country estate, this property delivers it all.

8503 Bean Blossom Road, Trafalgar

$580,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22023083 MLS

Pended and Sold

3764 S 475 W, Trafalgar

$549,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202504022 MLS

Full length covered front porch welcomes you to this beautiful custom built Lamb Lake home on 1.75 wooded acres w/full lake privileges. Open floorplan GR/Dining/Kitchen w/gorgeous wood ceiling, hardwood floors & cozy free standing gas fireplace gives rustic charm year round. Primary BR located on main level, full private bath w/garden tub & tile shower & walk-in closet. Stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash, granite coutertops, and gas range, roomy pantry. Main level opens to screened balcony overlooking woods, and includes TV and outdoor heater-great for entertaining! Upper level has family room (or whatever your needs may be), storage closet, laundry room, full bath w/double sinks & 2 spacious bedrooms. Over sized 2-car heated garage & workout room make up the basement level. Back yard has outdoor firepit. Enjoy all Lamb Lake has to offer with boating, skiing, fishing, swimming, private beach with shelter house, lots of wildlife and more! Home is located near entrance of Blossom Hollow Nature Preserve and walking trails.

4104 W Fox Trail, Trafalgar

$549,900

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22020369 MLS

Full length covered front porch welcomes you to this beautiful custom built Lamb Lake home on 1.75 wooded acres w/full lake privileges. Open floorplan GR/Dining/Kitchen w/gorgeous wood ceiling, hardwood floors & cozy free standing gas fireplace gives rustic charm year round. Primary BR located on main level, full private bath w/garden tub & tile shower & walk-in closet. Stainless steel appliances, tile backsplash, granite coutertops, and gas range, roomy pantry. Main level opens to screened balcony overlooking woods, and includes TV and outdoor heater-great for entertaining! Upper level has family room (or whatever your needs may be), storage closet, laundry room, full bath w/double sinks & 2 spacious bedrooms. Over sized 2-car heated garage & workout room make up the basement level. Back yard has outdoor firepit. Enjoy all Lamb Lake has to offer with boating, skiing, fishing, swimming, private beach with shelter house, lots of wildlife and more! Home is located near entrance of Blossom Hollow Nature Preserve and walking trails.

4104 W Fox Trail, Trafalgar

$650,000

22007466 MLS

Wooded recreational land with hills and ravines. Dense woods with Indiana hardwoods located on 700 South in Trafalgar. Still time to close on land before hunting season begins! The land cannot be divided and will only be sold as two parcels together. 5 miles southwest of Trafalgar, near Brown County. Indian Creek Schools. 683 foot of road frontage. Do not walk the land/acreage without an agent.

W 700 Road S, Trafalgar

$540,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22000544 MLS

The picturesque tree-lined driveway welcomes you to 5121 South 150 West! Well loved, this 4BR/3BA home is nestled on three beautiful acres in the country, yet less than five minutes away from the Town of Trafalgar and Indian Creek Schools! The home offers a great floor plan with spacious rooms throughout. On the main level find a welcoming foyer, an enormous living room with cozy gas fireplace, a breakfast room with astonishing views of the backyard, gardens, koi pond, and shared lake. The kitchen boasts stainless steel appliances, beautiful lighting, double pantries, and center island breakfast bar. An additional formal dining/sitting room, full bath, and laundry/utility room round out the main floor. Need a junior suite on the main floor? The dining/sitting room could easily be converted with access to an on-suite full bath. Upstairs you'll find the gigantic primary bedroom with sitting area, walk-in custom closet, and double sinks in the on-suite bath. There's plenty of space to add a coffee & tea bar to get your mornings started off right! Three good-sized secondary bedrooms and hall bath complete the upstairs. Natural light pours in through the many windows and skylights! There are numerous neat outdoor sitting areas/patios/decks/and not to mention the gorgeous wrap-around porch to use as entertaining spaces for family, friends, guests or relaxation! Other amenities include an oversized 2-car garage, water softener rough-in, solid wood six-panel doors throughout, raised garden beds, fire pit area, basketball court, and storage barn! You have to see it for yourself! Schedule your showing today!

5121 S 150 W, Trafalgar

$590,000

3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21989975 MLS

Welcome home to this wooded 5 acre beauty in the hills of Brown County! Completely remodeled and updated this home boasts 3 bedrooms 3 full bathrooms and ample storage!! Office space listed is currently being used as additional bedroom. Primary with stunning ensuite on main with additional bedroom and full bathroom. The huge open ceilings in the living room with floor to ceiling windows allow for tons of natural lighting. The kitchen is a dream! Complete with a HUGE pantry!! All stainless steel appliances stay in the kitchen to allow you to move right in and are only 2 years old. Step out to the 4 season sunroom from the primary or the living room. Equipped with its own heating and cooling system you will find your new favorite spot of this home. Now lets step upstairs. You will enter the loft area and 2 more bedrooms. Larger room has access to yet another deck to sit and enjoy the sounds of nature. Rounding out the upstairs with one more full bathroom, the laundry room and TONS of storage. This home has everything you can dream of. Lets not forget the expansive 4 car garage and fully encapsulated crawl space with spray foam insulation! Now that we have covered all the home has to offer lets take a stroll outdoors. Newly cut trails for walking or riding your 4wheelers around. Nice sized yard for entertaining but leaving tons of trees for privacy and seclusion. Plus plenty of parking for all your friends. This really is the dream home you've been looking for!!

7811 Bean Blossom Road, Trafalgar

$575,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 21983624 MLS

Welcome home to Locust Grove Estates! This spectacular family home is seeking its new owner. Large room sizes provide plenty of space for the family to spread out and the expansive decks leading to the pool provide lots of entertaining space. The primary bath has been updated with gorgeous tile and a tub suited for a Queen! The kitchen update was finished in the last six months. It features new cabinets, gorgeous tile backsplash and quartz countertops. Three large bonus spaces could be extra office space (SCIFiber Internet is connected), bedrooms, hobby rooms, music rooms...endless possibilities! This super-private 10 acre property backs up to the Laura Hare Preserve at Blossom Hollow, a privately-owned nature preserve with hiking trails, streams and wildlife. Enjoy the front porch with friends or a campfire in the fall. This home has so much to offer!

8959 S Laroche Drive, Trafalgar

$600,000

4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 21968824 MLS

Beautiful 4 BEDROOM + 2.5 BATH Home on Lamb Lake! Features: 2 Lots; Inground Pool w/NEW Cover; NEW HVAC System; NEW ROOF; Living Room w/Raised Ceilings; Dining Room; Kitchen w/Tile Floors + Center Island + Granite Countertops + Pughs Custom Cabinets + SS Appliances; Huge Family Room leading to Deck w/Fireplace & Wet Bar; Primary Bedroom w/Engineered Hardwood Floors + Dbl Sinks + Garden Tub + Large Tile Shower & Walk-In Closet; 3 Additional Great-Size Bedrooms; Laundry Room; Storage Area; Large Deck to Enjoy in Backyard + Open Concrete Patio & Awesome Pool in Private Backyard! This is a MUST SEE!

8043 S 500 W, Trafalgar

$535,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21968536 MLS

From outside to inside you can feel the creativity and love for this home. From the manicured lawn and landscape, through all the right finishes on the interior, to the dream-barn set up ready for work or play! This brick ranch is perched on 2 acres. The 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom home offers a split floor plan with updated bathrooms. The family room, dining room and kitchen are located in the heart of the home with quartz counter-tops, updated appliances, and soft close cabinets. Enjoy the eat in kitchen, formal dining room or take your dinner plans outside under the pergola near the pool. You'll find additional finished living space in the 3 year old pole barn. The finished workout room is heated and cooled with a storage loft above. So many updates and no details missed!

3491 S 25 W, Trafalgar

$550,000

3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21966441 MLS

Escape the hustle and bustle without sacrificing connectivity in this charming 3 bed, 2 bath log cabin - nestled in the heart of nature yet conveniently close to all amenities! This stunning home boasts an ideal location for remote work, equipped with high-speed internet and less than an hour's commute to downtown Indy and the airport. Indulge in the ultimate work-life balance with a fabulous walk out basement featuring a home gym, perfect for staying active and energized. Unwind after a long day in the luxurious new hot tub, or immerse yourself in the tranquility of nature on the expansive decks that make you feel like you're in a treehouse amidst your own private woods. Explore the beauty of your surroundings as you stroll along your very own private creek, perfect for mushroom foraging and connecting with nature. This log cabin offers the perfect blend of comfort & relaxation, so embrace the opportunity to live in harmony with both work and leisure in this enchanting woodland retreat. With the option to utilize the home as an Airbnb and the furniture available for sale, this is an opportunity not be missed for both personal enjoyment and potential income generation.

1932 W 725 S, Trafalgar

$525,000

2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21923520 MLS

LAKEFRONT! Beautiful Lamb Lake Log Home weekender or full-time selling TURN-KEY-Just bring your swim suits! On private wooded lakefront setting. Covered front porch, & 33x6 screened porch overlooking lake. Upper level MBR w/open sleeping loft (could be guest room), full bath. MBR has 2 closets. Custom kitchen cabts, SS appls, gas range, bkfst bar. Dining open to GR w/frplc & 2-story ceiling & built-in cabinets. BR2 located on main level, full bath w/free-standing tub w/shower. Laundry on main. Walkout bsmt has garage space for 2 cars end-to-end, plus unfinished area which could be finished into more living space. Side door opens to lower lakefront patio. 15x21 party deck w/elec overlooking lake, covered boat lift. 5 yr old metal roof.

7758 Timber Cliff Lane, Trafalgar

$500,000

3 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 21924004 MLS

2 story log cabin style home on 11+ acres in Indian Creek Schools! This home offers a main level master, 2 story stone fireplace in great room, finished basement, ample storage, 2 additional bedrooms upstairs and a bonus room that could easily be an 4th bedroom or office. This home is situated perfectly in the middle of the wooded property providing the for complete privacy. The exterior offers a peaceful covered porch, oversized back deck, 32x40 shop with concrete floors, electric and a loft. There is also an additional covered storage, a chicken coop, Johnson Co Fiber, apple trees and endless trails wrapping around the entire property. You will fall in love with this property the second you pull in the drive!

6968 S 300 W, Trafalgar

$575,000

4 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 21909348 MLS

THIS IS A MUST-SEE! BEAUTIFUL 4B HOME, 4 OUTBUILDINGS, A PRIVATE STOCKED LAKE, A 30X60 BARN PLUS PASTURE, and OVER 6 ACRES OF WOODS. This home has been meticulously maintained and has high-end upgrades throughout. The outbuildings are connected and consist of one bay with 16 ft ceilings and 30 amp RV hookup with a roll-up door, both 100 and 200 amp panels, 2 bays are vented for a car painting booth with lighting and extra exit door, and other 2 bays are set up for woodshop. The kitchen consists of double commercial-grade ovens with hood, a glass cooktop, a bosch dishwasher, and beautiful handcrafted woodwork cabinets which pull out extra long! BRING ON THE OFFERS! MOTIVATED SELLERS

4011 Locust Grove Drive, Trafalgar

Browse All Trafalgar IN Between $500K - $600K Properties for Sale

Between $500K - $600K Trafalgar Real Estate