Refine Search
Sort by
$600,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21956858 MLS
This home was once the private Brown County retreat of renowned Chicago Sun-Times courtroom sketch artist, Thomas Carollo. Nestled in the woods on a 5.7 ac lot just off SR 46 across from Salt Creek GC. Features hardwood and tile floors, two wood burning fireplaces, wet bar, four seasons sunroom w/heated floor, skylights and windows galore. Large kitchen has commercial range, breakfast room with built-in booth below unique corner window. Split primary suite with private deck. Open deck w/gas grill. Exterior painted with Rhino Shield for a longer lasting protection. This home is great for entertaining large groups and can be your own personal sanctuary. Former artist studio is now a game room. How will you use the artist studio?

2119 Fair Oaks Trail, Nashville

$607,652
3 Beds 3 Baths 21953238 MLS
Welcome to your Brown County dream home! Nestled in the woods in a quiet location that's convenient to Columbus and Nashville, this exquisite timber-framed home offers a perfect blend of rustic charm and modern amenities. As you step inside, you'll be greeted by the warmth of the red oak posts and beams that define the character of this architectural style. The kitchen boasts elegant Corian countertops, a natural gas stovetop island, and a breakfast bar, providing both style and functionality. There's a large sunlit dining room and adjacent living area with vaulted ceiling featuring a cozy gas log fireplace, creating an inviting atmosphere for gatherings. There are two bedrooms on the main level and an upstairs primary bedroom featuring an ensuite bath for added privacy and convenience and an open loft overlooking the main level living area. Lots of large windows throughout the home bring the surrounding natural beauty inside. The lower level provides access to the 2 car garage as well as additional living space including a family room perfect for movie night, a half bath, and a bonus room for crafts/hobbies/office/exercise, etc.... The family room opens to a large screened porch overlooking the serene shared lake and all the natural beauty surrounding the property. This residence boasts multiple and multi-level decks, each offering panoramic views of the surrounding woods. Picture yourself spending lazy afternoons on the deck or by the water's edge. If you need storage, the attached garage and the pole barn offer plenty of versatile space. The pole barn is insulated and equipped with electricity and is large enough to accommodate an RV, offering endless possibilities for hobbies or storage. This property enjoys the rare opportunity of access to natural gas (no propane tank to worry about here). Don't miss the opportunity to make this timber-framed haven your own!

6522 Kyra Court, Nashville

$337,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 21952780 MLS
Brown County Charm awaits you in this cozy 3 bedroom 2 bath over a full walkout basement situated on a 1.25+ acre lot in Annandale Estates just 2 miles from the artist village of Nashville IN. Do a little front porch sitting and enjoy the scenery from the covered porch of this rustic home. Wide wooden plank floors in the living room and dining area. Full deck off the dining room. Kitchen has been updated with solid surface counters and an island/bar. Fresh paint and lighting throughout the home. All bedrooms located on the main level have new carpet. The full basement has an office area, room for an additional family room, or game room. Large mechanical/storage room and an additional room that could be your workshop. Speaking of workshop there is a 24'x50' detached garage behind the home with 2 overhead doors and plenty of room for all your outdoor toys or crafts/hobbies! If your toys take up all the space in the garage there is a large carport near the front of the lot! This home has everything you have been looking for and ready for you to make it your home! Start enjoying Brown County Living on this peaceful wooded lot!

1389 Annandale Drive E, Nashville

$289,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 21952700 MLS
Back on market at no fault of seller! Quality built home, constructed with a lot of detail and craftsmanship. Ensuring structural integrity and longevity. This 3Bed/2BA home has a ton of potential with some updating. Poplar wood through out the home, real wood doors and trim. Full basement with a fire proof safe room, home has a wood burning stove, attached garage, 2 carports, upper deck with beautiful views, and an oversized 30x88 pole barn. The pole barn has a separate 200 AMP service, along with an oversized wood burning stove, a loft with ample storage, and a lean-to. Estate home, priced to make the updates needed. Being sold As-Is. Sitting on 3 acres with easy access to downtown Nashville, Brown County State Park, and 15 miles to Bloomington. Don't miss the opportunity to make this you dream home!

2126 State Road 46 W, Nashville

$495,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21950033 MLS
Atop a bluff and nestled among the trees, this beautiful and unique home rests on nearly four acres in Brown County. The forty-foot enclosed front porch boasts a gorgeous view of a private lake and features a Brown County stone fireplace, perfect for cooking out or enjoying your views with great ambiance. Rustic charm continues throughout the home's open concept design with the kitchen, dining room and living room all enjoying barn beams and a custom log bar. To continue the allure of this cabin, the living room has an amazing eighteen-foot Brown County stone fireplace. The Primary Suite is on the main floor with a whirlpool tub and custom built-in bed. Upstairs you will find two additional bedrooms, loft and an additional full bathroom. This home also has a basement, adding additional space for entertaining. The list of amazing features also includes solid hard wood floors throughout the home, a Juliet balcony, custom light fixtures, and many more touches that have been sourced locally from antique stores--a true antique enthusiast's dream. This property also boasts an additional two-story garage and a separate small cabin that could be used as an artist's studio or playhouse. Easy access to Nashville and a quick commute to Columbus. Truly a must see!

468 Dimension Lane, Nashville

$296,000
1 Baths 21952112 MLS
This unique property offers an incredible opportunity for both business and investment. This versatile space is currently configured as an office but holds vast potential for customization to suit your specific needs. Step into the main building and be greeted by a spacious reception area, perfect for welcoming clients and guests. The well-designed layout boasts a board room - the ideal setting for meetings and brainstorming sessions. With nine workspaces, there's ample room for your team to collaborate and thrive. Need privacy? No worries! This property also includes a private office, allowing you to focus on important tasks without interruptions. Looking to invest in real estate? We have you covered! The second building on the property offers an additional source of income through rental opportunities. Embrace the potential of passive income while enjoying the convenience of having multiple revenue streams.

158 N Jefferson Street, Nashville

$310,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 21950360 MLS
Retreat to this cozy log cabin to commune with nature, grow your own crops or open an artisan studio. Out buildings include a 24'x32' studio/workshop with water and a firing closet used by a previous artist/owner as well as 24'x24' garage/barn with a carport and an upper level loft. The two plus acres on the east side of Salt Creek Road are ready for spring gardening with a fenced area to protect your harvest. There is also room for a small pasture for animals. The primary bedroom is located on the main level and includes a private half bath. A charming second bedroom is upstairs with hardwood floors and a wall of closet space to meet your storage needs. A wood-burning fireplace with an insert is the focal point in the bright living room and a cozy spot to curl up during cool evenings. Hardwood floors and beamed ceilings enhance the cabin feel. The updated the kitchen has stainless steel appliances, including in 2022 a new refrigerator, stainless pull out shelves in the cabinet bases, quartz counter tops and a new sink/faucet. Hand painted and fired tiles in the kitchen and bathroom were almost certainly crafted by a previous artist/owner. Lots of pantry space. Other improvements since 2020 are a new HVAC system, additional shelving, some new windows, a new refrigerator and washing machine, excavation/grading, new gutters and downspouts and a new wood-burning stove in the dining area. In 2022, a new water heater was installed. Beautiful flower beds and garden areas. Spacious studio area with water and electric for hobbies, storage and other endeavors. Quiet secluded meadow behind the studio is ready for a firepit and entertaining. There may even be a morel patch on site.

1650 Salt Creek Road, Nashville

$238,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 21951171 MLS
This charming 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom ranch home offers the perfect blend of comfort and convenience. Ideally situated between Nashville and Columbus, this property promises a lifestyle of country living with quick access to restaurants and shopping. As you step inside, you will find a large picture window to enjoy nature's view. Walk through the dining room to be greeted by a spacious family room. The beautiful hardwood floors in the family room create a cozy atmosphere, while the raised beamed ceiling adds an extra touch of character. The focal point of this room is the stunning Brown County stone fireplace. The kitchen offers ample cabinet space, making meal preparation a breeze. The bedrooms have new closet doors with the primary bedroom having an ensuite bathroom. Stepping outside, you'll find beautiful landscaping and a large backyard that's perfect for outdoor activities, gardening, or simply relaxing in the fresh country air. In addition to the attached 1-car garage, the property boasts an oversized 2-car detached garage with workshop space. Whether you're a car enthusiast, a hobbyist, or simply need extra storage, this garage provides plenty of space. This property is the perfect place to call home for those who appreciate the charm of a ranch-style residence and the tranquility of Brown County living.

4898 State Road 46 E, Nashville

$350,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 21951269 MLS
BROWN COUNTY RETREAT NESTLED ON A 5.5 AC HILLTOP SETTING OVERLOOKING PRIVATE POND! MARKET READY CLASSIC 2-BED 2-BATH COTTAGE WITH FULL FINISHED WALK-OUT BASEMENT * DIRECT ACCESS TO MULTI-LEVEL DECK FROM EITHER LEVEL OR BOARDWALK * SPACIOUS INTERIOR THAT IS OPEN & CONNECTIVE FEATURES CATHEDRAL CEILING & OVERSIZED WINDOWS FOR SPECTALULAR SCENIC VIEWS NO MATTER THE SEASON * NEW MAIN LEVEL LVP FLOORING & INTERIOR PAINT THROUGHOUT * OAK CABINETRY E-I-KITCHEN W/GAS COOKING, CTR ISLAND, NEW SINK/FAUCET * LOWER LEVEL F/R, DEN & JACUZZI BATH FEATURES CERAMIC TILE WITH SUN TOUCH RADIANT HEAT * STONE FIREPLACE * CAPITVATING SURROUNDINGS WITH ABUNDANT NATURE & PRIVATE POND FOR FISHING * 1008 SF DET GARAGE W/15 X 15 HEATED ROOM & UPPER LEVEL FLOORED ATTIC - IDEAL FOR ARTIST STUDIO * REVERSE OSMOSIS SYSTEM * WATER SOFTENER PAID * PROPANE TANK RENTED * 26 MI TO COLUMBUS * 30 MI TO BLOOMINGTON * 60 MI TO INDY * CORPORATE TRUST OWNED BEING SOLD IN AS-IS CONDITION * ONE LOOK & YOU WILL WANT TO MAKE THIS MEMORY MAKER YOURS TODAY!

2689 SR 135 Road S, Nashville

$684,000
3 Beds 5 Baths 21950827 MLS
Stunning custom built log cabin home on 1.5 acres nestled in the Hoosier National State Forest. Close proximity to Lake Monroe with boat slip access. Multi-level deck for enjoying the gorgeous views at different vantage points. Lake views from fall to early spring. Walking up to the home you're greeted with a covered front porch and large wooden handmade French Doors. Inside find an open concept main floor, soaring ceilings and huge stone fireplace that commands attention. The kitchen has custom cabinetry with plenty of storage , granite counter tops and island with butcher block counter top and copper sink. Large dining room with space for hosting plenty of guests for all your gatherings. Off the living room, enjoy the view as you sip your morning coffee on the 36x11 deck . The main floor also boasts an office with shelving and main floor laundry. Office could also double as an additional bedroom. Main floor bedroom with ensuite great for weekend guests. Upstairs you'll find a great loft space, another bedroom with ensuite and the Master bedroom with plentiful closet space. The master bath houses a clawfoot soaker tub and shower. Back downstairs to the basement where you'll find a 2nd living room with stone fireplace, full bathroom newly remodeled, storage room, additional laundry room, large workshop and walkout deck. The attached 2-car garage with brand new heater can also be accessed from the basement. Whole home generator, 2 heat pumps with 3 zone system whole house cell phone booster. A slice of paradise in one of the most beautiful natural settings in the state!

8513 Alma Street, Nashville

$505,575
3 Beds 4 Baths 21950123 MLS
This Brown County tourist rental is a sanctuary for nature lovers, providing tranquility & comfort. Upon entry, you are embraced by the warmth of the stone fireplace that graces the living room. Upstairs are 2 bedrooms each with their own bathrooms. A balcony off the primary bedroom is the perfect place to drink your morning coffee or read a book. From the kitchen or living room, step outside onto the spacious deck, which offers a magnificent vantage point overlooking the lush woods. In the walk-out lower level is a large family room with a wood-burning fireplace and a game room that was once a bedroom. This area provides an ideal spot for socializing, playing games, or indulging in cozy evenings by the fire. Outside, relax in the hot tub under the stars or tell stories around the firepit. In addition to the main house, there is a charming one-bedroom 640 sq ft apartment located above the oversized 2-car garage. This versatile space is perfect for accommodating additional guests, offering them privacy and comfort while they enjoy their stay. For those who need to connect online, high speed fiber internet is available at the property. With its new 4 bedroom septic, this property is currently zoned as a tourist rental to sleep 8. Schedule your showing today!

4299 Kelly Reed Road, Nashville

$349,900
3 Beds 2 Baths 21949202 MLS
Nestled into the woods in beautiful Brown County is this 3 bedroom, 2 bath home that has been fully updated and is ready for immediate occupancy! Enjoy bright rooms and lots of windows offering views of local wildlife. Modern lighting, new floors and bathrooms make this one a stunner! Sit in your living room in front of the Brown County stone fireplace and watch deer graze in the field that is bordered by a small creek. The covered porch is a perfect place for watching the sunrise. The fireplace downstairs affords a cozy spot to wind down. The very spacious garage/workshop needs a small amount of work to be finished, but is large enough to accomodate any projects you have in mind. Just a five minute drive to the center of Nashville, schedule your private showing today!

2028 Wallow Hollow Road, Nashville

$410,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21949695 MLS
Brown Co, Move in ready! This Pine Tree Hills 3BR 3BA Home is in like new condition. Very close to Nashville, restaurants and entertainment. All mechanicals have been updated . Carefree living with a beautiful view of the woods. Snow removal, yard mowing, trash collection, common area, lake, use of the Clubhouse & walking trails are all part of this development. A safe place to spend retirement or have a family. Finished basement with MB on main level. Screened & open deck space offer plenty of room for entertaining, plus a huge 16x36 open family room on the walkout lower level. Connected to Municipal water and sewer, with a 2 car garage and a newer roof make this a very comfortable place to reside. 15min to either Bloomington or Columbus, and just 40 min. to Indianapolis.

105 Pine Lake Circle, Nashville

$250,000
3 Beds 1 Baths 21948833 MLS
This charming ranch style 3BD/1BA home is in a peaceful valley perched along a western-facing hillside near Brown Co. State Park, 0.5 miles from Story, IN and 2 miles from the Horseman's Camp Entrance to the park. This property is manicured with tiering paths, gardens, sitting areas, stone landscaping, a seasonal stream, and a gravel driveway that recently had new stone placed on it. The home features a primary/secondary bedroom with a Brown County stone fireplace, a closed in patio off the kitchen, a porch that is covered around the front and side, and partial basement. The home also features an outdoor Central Boiler wood furnace that can be used to heat the home and the hot water heater for efficiency, but the home is also equipped with propane. The property features a nice 32x32 barn with board and batten siding, electricity, "hay" loft, and workshop area, and there may be room for a horse or two. There is also a nice 8x16 storage shed with a fire-pit nearby. There is a detached 2-car garage. Septic system was installed in 2004.

6239 Susie Ayers Road, Nashville

$325,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 21948152 MLS
This charming house is nestled on 8.56 acres of serene land in picturesque Brown County. With a partially finished walk-out basement, it offers versatile living space. The property boasts the beauty of mature trees, providing natural shade & tranquility. Inside, you'll find 3 cozy bedrooms & 2 well-appointed bathrooms. The open kitchen is perfect for culinary enthusiasts, while the wood-burning fireplace adds warmth and character to the living space. One of the standout features of this house is the large deck, offering a captivating view of the lush woods, making it an ideal spot for relaxation & outdoor entertaining. With its proximity to Nashville, Bloomington, & Columbus, you have easy access to a variety of attractions and amenities.

3899 Lower Schooner Road, Nashville

$395,500
21946633 MLS
TOURIST HOME POTENTIAL!! This gem is listed B2, but with a few modifications could be used as a tourist rental! Walking distance to the heart of the village, restaurants, shops, shows!! Or, if you'd rather, continue to use this as an office space. COMPLETELY remodeled in 2018, including new HVAC, plumbing, electrical, flooring, roof, to name a few! This property has 11 designated parking spaces, high speed internet, GREAT visibility and traffic flow. Current floor plan is open, with 2 half baths and a full kitchen. A little remodeling could turn this into a 2/3 bedroom 2 full bath space with an open room for entertaining. Yard in back has a firepit & small storage shed. This is an investment property you don't want to miss out on!!

30 Artist Drive, Nashville

$290,750
3 Beds 1 Baths 21946805 MLS
Welcome to your dream farmhouse retreat! This picturesque property offers the perfect blend of modern updates and original farmhouse charm. Updates include new windows, new paint, new flooring, renovated kitchen and bath, and on nearly an acre and a half, this home is a rare find in a prime location. The kitchen is a chef's delight, with ample counter space, updated appliances, and stylish cabinetry. The bathroom has been thoughtfully updated with contemporary fixtures and a spa-like feel. This property retains its original farmhouse character, as part of the original "Brown Homestead". Situated near the state park and downtown Nashville, you'll have access to trails, outdoor adventures, shopping, dining, and entertainment.

1190 Old State Road 46, Nashville

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.