Quick Nashville IN MLS Search

Browse All Nashville IN Between $400K - $500K Properties for Sale

568 Mcgee Rd, Nashville
$450,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202533175 MLS
The attention to detail on this renovation has to be seen to appreciate it. Peaceful Valley Construction spared no expense on what should be considered a new build. Everything...EVERYTHING is NEW. The quality of craftsmanship found in this home is second to none, and is the same quality they put into each custom home they build. Quality finishes are found throughout and only the best materials available by top of the line manufacturers were used. You won't find a nicer home on the market. LP Smart siding and trim, pex plumbing, high efficiency top rated instant hot water heater, high efficiency dual fuel HVAC, all new electrical, Sherwin Williams top of the line paint used inside and out, and Crestline windows and doors are just a few examples that you will notice immediately. High quality laminate and luxury vinyl plank flooring is found throughout the home to continue with the low maintenance theme. The eat in kitchen is amazing with custom cabinets, beautiful oak hardwood countertops, high end appliances, and a stunning backsplash. The large living room is highlighted by the repurposed barn beam mantle over the gas log fireplace. The split floorplan features a spacious master suite with a large bath and wonderful tile shower. The lower level offers a family room, spacious bonus room providing more storage or however you choose to utilize it, and a 2 car garage that features a wi-fi garage door opener with camera. Sitting on 1 acre and located in a peaceful neighborhood, this awesome property is extremely convenient to the best of everything in Brown County including downtown Nashville, Brown County Music Center, Hard Truth and the Brown County State Park!

568 Mcgee Rd, Nashville

123 Ridgeway Dr, Nashville
$365,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 202536723 MLS
Your Forever Home is waiting in Beautiful Brown County Welcome to this exceptional new construction, meticulously designed for those seeking luxury, comfort, and modern living. Move-in ready and thoughtfully crafted, this home perfectly combines high-end finishes with practical functionality, offering the ideal retreat in the heart of scenic Nashville, IN. The primary bedroom is designed for privacy and comfort. Vaulted ceilings create an open, airy feel, while the walk-in shower, double sinks, and generous walk-in closet offer the ultimate in convenience and luxury. Additional closet space and linen storage make organization a breeze. The heart of the home, the Great Room boasts vaulted ceilings, filling the space with natural light and providing a perfect spot for relaxation or entertaining. The kitchen is a chef's dream, featuring granite countertops, a central island, high-end stainless steel appliances, and a pantry for optimal storage. The oversized laundry room is equipped with a utility sink and ample space for storage and organization, making household chores more manageable. Two generously sized bedrooms, each with 9' ceilings, provide comfort and space. These bedrooms share a full bathroom with a tiled shower, offering both style and function. Enjoy year-round comfort with an attached garage that features a mini split system, perfect for maintaining an ideal temperature no matter the season. Access to the crawlspace is provided in the garage. Step outside and unwind. The welcoming front porch is perfect for enjoying the outdoors, while the private back patio with a privacy fence provides a peaceful retreat for relaxation or entertaining. This home is built to last, with top-tier materials and construction methods. Triple-pane windows ensure energy efficiency and noise reduction, while 2x6 construction and spray foam insulation provide superior durability and comfort. The tall crawl space with a poured concrete floor adds an extra layer of stability and accessibility. Beautiful cement siding is accented with Brown County Stone, and the stamped concrete sidewalk adds a touch of elegance to the exterior. This home truly offers everything you've been looking for—modern finishes, thoughtful design, and energy-efficient features—all nestled in the scenic charm of Brown County. It’s the perfect place to call home.

123 Ridgeway Dr, Nashville

4595 Plum Creek Rd, Nashville
$475,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 202631164 MLS
Hobby farm on 6 acres provides a two-story house with 2560 SF, a 768SF pole barn, an enclosed shelter at driveway entrance, fenced-in fields, and even an active chicken coop! The property is close to SR45 & Lake Lemon, with easy access to Bloomington & the Indiana University campus, and to SR135 in Brown County. It also abuts the 42-mile Tecumseh Trail (google it!) that connects Lake Monroe to the Morgan-Monroe State Forest HQ. Outside features & scenery support the flexible lifestyle you desire. Turning into the drive, on the right you’ll appreciate the enclosed shelter, once used for children waiting for the school bus. It can also be used as a drop-off site for package delivery. Continuing, you'll see the pole barn with concrete floor, electric and a large sliding access door. Immediately beyond the pole barn is a fenced-in field, perfect for your animal friends. Open the pole barn service door to allow them shelter during inclement weather. This area also opens to the enclosed deck in back of the house, so you could leave that deck door open to allow shelter closer to home. Next is the residence, and beyond that is a chicken coop, currently home to eight of Brown County's finest free-range chickens that produce the best eggs! The house features an open floor plan with hardwood floors. Radiant floor heat is efficient and provides a nice ambience. Fiber-optic connectivity is available for the internet jockey. The living room provides picture windows on front & side walls to enjoy the panorama. The large kitchen includes black stainless steel appliances and offers lots of cabinetry, a pantry and huge kitchen island. The corner sink windows let you enjoy nature while you tend to culinary duties. A separate dining area is large enough for an eight-chair table. The French doors beyond the dining area open to the screened-in porch in back, which itself opens to a large uncovered deck. A large full bath includes space for the washer & dryer and access to the mechanical room, home to radiant floor heat controls, Navien in-line water heater, and Freije water conditioning system. Last on the main level is a large bedroom that could also serve as a home office. Upstairs, the huge primary suite includes a nook for enjoying your favorite morning beverage, a large closet/storage space, and a full bath with jetted tub. Another room upstairs can be used as either an office space, gaming room, or, with a wardrobe, a third bedroom.

4595 Plum Creek Rd, Nashville

1331 N State Road 135, Nashville
$427,500
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22102970 MLS
Experience custom rare new construction in the heart of Brown County, approximately a one mile walk through Artist Drive neighborhood to downtown Nashville's galleries, shops, dining & entertainment. Tucked among mature trees with wooded surroundings & seasonal sunsets, this thoughtfully designed 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath ranch offers 1,953 square feet of quality craftsmanship, functional design & distinctive local character. The open-concept living, dining & kitchen spaces feature warm wood-tone flooring, quartz countertops, all-plywood soft-close cabinetry, tile backsplash & included stainless appliance package. French doors lead to the 26x10 screened rear porch & attached grilling patio creating an inviting extension of the living space with views of the fenced backyard & surrounding trees. A functional layout with buffered primary suite placement offers added privacy, while the primary bath features heated tile flooring, dual vanity, tiled walk-in shower & generous walk-in closet space. Three additional bedrooms provide flexibility for guests, office space, hobbies or creative use. The full hall bath is thoughtfully designed with tiled shower walls & a split configuration separating the vanity from the stool and shower area for added convenience during busy routines. Everyday function was equally prioritized with a thoughtfully designed laundry/mudroom featuring utility sink, included washer & dryer, integrated walk-in pantry storage & direct access to the oversized attached garage. Additional features include abundant storage throughout, 5 star insulation package, public sewer & water service, fully fenced rear yard, mature trees & generous parking. No HOA or CCRs. A custom tree carving by Brown County artist Chris Trotter creates a memorable front-yard focal point and meaningful connection to the area's artistic heritage. Enjoy near-downtown access paired with the natural beauty, craftsmanship, and creative spirit that make Brown County so distinct.

1331 N State Road 135, Nashville

972 Helmsburg Road, Nashville
$455,000
2 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22087115 MLS
Less than a mile from downtown Nashville, this unique and meticulously maintained Brown County home has been lovingly owned by the same family since it was built. Originally designed as a 3-BR home across two levels, thoughtful modifications created two separate living spaces, offering exceptional flexibility. Currently configured with a kitchen on each level, the home is ideal for hosting guests or generating income through long-term rental or short-term homestay. It can also be easily converted back to its original 3-BR layout if desired. Inside, the home features a striking double-sided fireplace shared between the living room and the primary bedroom, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere throughout the main level. Attractive high-quality laminate plank flooring runs through the home. Efficient mini-split heat pumps provide comfortable heating and cooling on both levels. One of the home's most distinctive architectural features is the charming cupola, adding character while providing stunning 360-degree views of the surrounding landscape. Outdoors, a covered deck on the main level and covered patio below overlook the shared stocked lake, creating peaceful spaces for relaxing with morning coffee, entertaining guests, or simply enjoying the natural beauty of Brown County. The property also offers exceptional workspace and storage options. A detached two-car garage includes extra storage, a dedicated office area, and a craft room ideal for hobbies, a workshop, or creative studio space. The barn/outbuilding with electricity features an enclosed sitting room that could easily serve as a workshop or studio. With its unique architectural charm, flexible living spaces, beautiful outdoor areas, and versatile outbuildings, this property offers a rare opportunity to enjoy the Brown County lifestyle just minutes from downtown Nashville's shops, dining, and entertainment.

972 Helmsburg Road, Nashville

2398 Country Club Road, Nashville
$400,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22076493 MLS
Welcome to your own slice of Brown County charm! This stunning log cabin blends rustic character with modern comfort, starting with a breathtaking stone fireplace crafted from authentic Brown County stone and finished with a custom stone-cut mantle - the true heart of the home. Painted wood plank floors flow throughout the main and upper levels, creating a warm, cohesive feel that perfectly balances cabin coziness with a fresh, updated look. The open-concept kitchen brings a modern, luxurious touch with granite countertops, beautiful cabinetry, and a seamless flow into the dining area situated beneath a dramatic vaulted ceiling - ideal for hosting or everyday living. The primary suite feels like a true cabin-retreat, highlighted by warm wood details, open loft views overlooking the main living space and a gorgeous modern bathroom offering a spacious walk-in closet, updated vanity and walk-in shower. The fully finished walk-out basement features the third bedroom and bathroom with a beautiful two-bowl vanity and walk-in shower. that could be used as the primary suite, a guest suite, in-law space or additional living area. The choice is yours! Step outside and soak it all in - enjoy coffee on the wraparound front porch or unwind on the covered back patio, surrounded by nature and starry skies. Located on a quiet road, this thoughtfully updated home delivers peaceful, cabin-style living just minutes from amenities, Nashville restaurants, local shops, and Brown County's outdoor attractions. Schedule your showing today and experience the warmth and character this cabin home has to offer!

2398 Country Club Road, Nashville

Mt Liberty Road, Nashville
$475,000
22071894 MLS
Nestled in the heart of scenic Brown County, this 30 acre wooded property offers a rare opportunity to own a pristine piece of Indiana's natural beauty. Towering mature hardwoods, including white oak, hickory, and maple, create a peaceful forest canopy ideal for those seeking privacy, recreation, or a future homestead. The land features a gentle, rolling topography with multiple potential building sites, perfect for a secluded cabin retreat, hunting lodge, or dream home surrounded by nature. With extensive road frontage, the property provides easy access and flexible options for driveway placement or potential subdivision. Wildlife is abundant-deer, turkey, and songbirds roam freely through the woods, making it an ideal setting for outdoor enthusiasts. The property's untouched landscape also offers long-term value with its marketable timber, offering both natural beauty and investment potential. Whether you're looking to build now or simply hold a stunning tract of Indiana woodland for the future, this parcel offers a blend of tranquility, accessibility, and opportunity that's increasingly hard to find. Electricity and other utilities are nearby, and the land's layout provides the perfect mix of seclusion and convenience-just minutes from the charming town of Nashville, yet worlds away from the hustle and bustle. If you've dreamed of owning your own forest retreat, this 30-acre wooded sanctuary delivers peace, privacy, and potential in every direction.

Mt Liberty Road, Nashville

5284 T C Steele Road, Nashville
$456,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22069454 MLS
Nestled in a peaceful valley and surrounded by nature, this cozy log-sided two-story home offers rustic charm with modern comfort. Backing directly onto Yellowwood State Forest right outside the back door and just under 2 miles from the Crooked Creek boat ramp at Lake Monroe via scenic T.C. Steele Road, the location is a nature lover's dream. With 3 bedrooms and 2 baths across approximately 1,850 sq. ft, this comfy retreat is ideal for full-time living, weekend escapes, or creative inspiration. The open-concept interior features expansive windows that fill the space with natural light and frame serene woodland views. A beautiful Brown County stone fireplace anchors the great room, while a loft overlooks the space from the spacious second-story primary suite. Step outside to over 3 acres of wooded privacy, complete with a flowing creek. A full wraparound covered porch and large attached deck invite you to savor morning coffee, an evening glass of wine, and the changing seasons. The property also includes a rustic hunting cabin (ready for a little TLC) with built-in bunks, electricity, woodstove, and covered porch, plus a powered shed and attached storage barn for tools, gear, or hobbies. Built in 2000, the home sits in one of Indiana's most scenic regions. Whether you're gardening, hiking, or simply unwinding in quiet solitude, this property offers a perfect balance of seclusion and connection to nature. Experience the timeless beauty of Brown Couty living - where each sunrise and sunset feels like an invitation to slow down, breathe deeply, and truly feel at home. Fiber optic internet service recently connected.

5284 T C Steele Road, Nashville

826 Freeman Ridge Road, Nashville
$450,000
2 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22066056 MLS
"Twin Views": Nestled on a peaceful ridge overlooking the scenic hills of Brown County, this storybook cottage home has an abundance of charm along with long range seasonal views in front and back, on desirable Freeman Ridge. The southern boundary of the 3.75 acre parcel is shared with The Nature Conservancy. Inside, it features inviting living areas filled with warmth and character and hardwood floors throughout. A large family room with expansive windows is great for gatherings. The central living room features warm poplar siding, a fireplace with a beautiful hearth, and bay windows. Multiple flex spaces provide options for a home office, studio, or hobby areas. The kitchen and dining spaces offer another of the three fireplaces and access to the expansive rear covered deck. This area also has one of two sets of stairs to the second story. The second story is the location of the primary bedroom suite and two flex spaces currently set up as offices/libraries, one being an open loft overlooking the family room. The third fireplace is located in the primary bedroom. A rear balcony on the second floor provides peaceful scenic views. A partial basement is mostly unfinished with laundry facilities, mechanicals, and access to the partial conditioned crawl space. The home also has a back-up generator. A large A-frame garage/shed provides room for another vehicle or extra storage space. Whether you're seeking a full-time residence or a weekend getaway, this home offers an exceptional foundation to personalize and make your own. Located in the heart of Brown County, you'll be close to Nashville's art galleries, local shops, dining, and outdoor recreation-including Brown County State Park and miles of scenic hiking trails. The Hitz-Rhodehamel Nature Preserve, offering miles of hiking trails, is also located about 1/4 mile past the property. The Seller has purchased a Home Warranty through HSA that will transfer to the buyer.

826 Freeman Ridge Road, Nashville

2124 Fair Oaks Trail, Nashville
$390,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22065417 MLS
This beautifully maintained three-bedroom, two-bath home in the peaceful Fair Oaks subdivision, just across from Salt Creek Golf Course and minutes from Brown County State Park and downtown Nashville. Set on a wooded lot surrounded by mature trees, this property offers the perfect combination of comfort, privacy, and convenience in one of Brown County's most desirable settings. Inside, natural light from brand-new skylights fills the open living spaces, highlighting the warmth of a cozy wood-burning fireplace at the heart of the home. A newly installed roof provides lasting peace of mind, while the open layout connects the kitchen, dining, and living areas seamlessly for comfortable living and entertaining. Large windows frame the wooded views outside, creating a tranquil connection with nature year-round. The finished basement adds valuable flexibility, featuring a spacious studio or second living area ideal for a creative workspace, media room, or home gym. Outdoors, expansive decks and a peaceful koi pond and water feature, create a private oasis for relaxing or hosting guests. Beautiful garden spaces provide room for flowers, herbs, or vegetables and blend perfectly with the surrounding trees and natural landscape. A heated four-car garage offers exceptional space for vehicles, tools, or hobbies, while a whole-house generator ensures comfort and security through every season. Snow removal for subdivision access roads makes winter living easy and carefree. This home's location offers the best of Brown County living-peaceful and scenic yet close to recreation, shopping, and entertainment. Enjoy golf across the road at Salt Creek, explore nearby trails at Brown County State Park, or visit Nashville's art galleries and restaurants just minutes away. With its new roof, new skylights, wood-burning fireplace, finished basement studio, koi pond, whole-house generator, and heated four-car garage, this Fair Oaks retreat blends rustic warmth with modern comfort.

2124 Fair Oaks Trail, Nashville

123 Ridgeway Drive, Nashville
$365,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22062022 MLS
Your Forever Home is Waiting in Beautiful Brown County Welcome to this exceptional new construction, designed for those seeking luxury, comfort, and modern living. Move-in ready and thoughtfully crafted, this home combines high-end finishes with practical functionality, offering the ideal retreat in the heart of scenic Nashville, IN. The primary bedroom is a private sanctuary with vaulted ceilings, a walk-in shower, double sinks, and a generous walk-in closet. Additional closet space and linen storage ensure ultimate organization. The Great Room is the heart of the home, featuring vaulted ceilings that fill the space with natural light. It flows seamlessly into the kitchen, complete with granite countertops, a central island, high-end stainless steel appliances, and a pantry for ample storage. The oversized laundry room includes a utility sink and provides plenty of room for storage and organization. Two generously sized bedrooms, each with 9' ceilings, share a full bathroom with a beautiful tiled shower. Enjoy year-round comfort with an attached garage featuring a mini-split system for temperature control. The garage also provides easy access to the crawlspace for added convenience. Step outside to unwind on the welcoming front porch or relax in your private backyard, with a privacy fence surrounding the back patio-the perfect space for entertaining or quiet moments. Built with top-tier materials, this home includes triple-pane windows, 2x6 construction, and spray foam insulation for energy efficiency. The tall crawl space with a poured concrete floor adds stability and easy access. The cement siding, accented with Brown County Stone, and a stamped concrete sidewalk add elegance to the curb appeal. This home offers everything you've been looking for-modern finishes, thoughtful design, and energy-efficient features-all nestled in the scenic charm of Brown County. It's the perfect place to call home.

123 Ridgeway Drive, Nashville

Start Your Search

Listings courtesy of MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative as distributed by MLS GRID.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.


Between $400K - $500K Nashville Real Estate

Our website features the best real estate search for between $400k - $500k properties available in Nashville and surrounding areas. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official Realtor®’s database every 15 minutes. 

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire. 

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood! 

Considering selling or refinancing your home? Get an INSTANT property valuation now!

Contact us today to find out how we can be of assistance to you!

How much is your home worth?

Get instant property value now!