Refine Search
Map
Sort by
$2,390,000
3 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 22123956 MLS
An Entertainer's Dream on Lamb Lake! Nestled on a pristine, expansive wooded waterfront double lot on beautiful Lamb Lake, this one-of-a-kind property offers privacy, character, and exceptional spaces for entertaining. Conveniently located on the north side of the community, the home is less than an hour from both Indianapolis and Bloomington. Tucked away in a quiet cove with more than 250 feet of waterfront, the home showcases distinctive mid-century modern architecture designed by William J. Fox and custom built by Gene Perkins. Inside, you'll find two primary en-suites with beautiful water views, a butler's pantry, dedicated Theatre Room, oversized commercial windows on lake side, indoor lap pool & hot tub w/ modern updates/features throughout. A spacious, multipurpose garage features radiant-heated floors, full view glass garage doors, complete with an office and additional living quarters above-ideal for guests, family, working from home, activities, or additional entertaining space. Outside, an expansive dock takes full advantage of the lakefront setting, offering three covered boat slips with lifts, rooftop deck and plenty of room to enjoy life on the water. A rare combination of architectural character, wooded privacy, generous entertaining spaces, and direct access to Lamb Lake, this distinctive waterfront retreat is truly one of a kind and a must see in person!

7502 S Susan Lane, Trafalgar
$1,499,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 22124032 MLS
Welcome to Lamb Lake living at its finest. This exceptional 4-bedroom, 3.5-bath North Shore home offers an abundance of space, privacy, and endless opportunities to enjoy lake life. With panoramic views overlooking one of the largest and most private coves on Lamb Lake, this property delivers a true vacation-at-home experience. Designed around the lake, the home brings the water into nearly every room through expansive views and thoughtful placement. The main level features a welcoming formal living area surrounded by custom built-ins, a spacious eat-in kitchen, comfortable TV room, and a luxurious primary suite. The kitchen is ideal for both everyday living and entertaining, with a large center island, generous cabinetry, and plenty of storage. Spacious primary suite is a private retreat, complete with a comfortable sitting area, two walk-in closets, and an updated bath featuring a separate shower and freestanding soaking tub. Connecting the entire main level is a full-length composite deck-the perfect place to start the morning with coffee as the sun rises over the peaceful cove, or gather with friends and family for an evening of grilling after a day on the water. The walk-out lower level is perfectly designed for entertaining and lake weekends, offering three additional bedrooms, two full bathrooms, a large bar, gas fireplace, billiards area, and dedicated game space. Step outside to a second full-length composite deck, providing even more room for outdoor seating, dining, and entertaining. Updated composite steps lead from the lower deck down to your private dock, where a covered boat slip and spacious dock area create the perfect launching point for days spent on Lamb Lake. Whether you're boating, swimming, fishing, entertaining, or simply taking in the views, this home offers the quintessential lake lifestyle in a truly private and picturesque setting.

7511 S Poplar Point Drive, Trafalgar
$1,499,999
4 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22122748 MLS
Discover a rare combination of privacy, acreage and modern amenities at this exceptional Trafalgar property on 15+ acres with a private pond. Offering a finished walkout basement and an impressive detached garage/outbuilding, this property provides the space and flexibility that can be difficult to find in Central Indiana. The updated kitchen features Cambria quartz countertops, KitchenAid appliances and an electric induction range. The primary bathroom has also been beautifully updated with Cambria quartz, custom cabinetry and travertine tile. Additional improvements include newer roofs on the home and garage, five Velux skylights, updated landscaping, newer lower-level flooring and newer carpet in the primary bedroom and stairway. Enjoy geothermal heating and cooling with a loop system in the pond, underground electric service and JC Fiber high-speed fiber-optic internet, an excellent feature for today's remote and hybrid-work lifestyle. The detached garage provides outstanding space for vehicles, equipment, hobbies or a workshop and includes a vehicle service pit. Outdoors, enjoy your private pond, fire pit area and acres of land for recreation, fishing, outdoor activities or simply enjoying the privacy of country living. For buyers relocating to Indiana or searching for a home with acreage south of Indianapolis, this property offers an opportunity to enjoy a private rural setting while remaining connected to the greater Central Indiana employment market. Whether you're searching for an Indianapolis-area relocation home, Johnson County acreage, a Trafalgar home with a pond, a private country estate or simply more space outside the city, 8565 S 500 W deserves to be experienced in person.

8565 S 500 W, Trafalgar
$1,399,999
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 22115488 MLS
Rare opportunity to own 39 beautiful acres in Trafalgar! This exceptional property features three fenced pastures, two creeks, abundant deer and turkey, fiber internet, and a whole-house generator. The home offers fresh paint, new LVP flooring on the main level, and a beautifully remodeled primary bath. The finished basement with 10-foot ceilings includes an ideal in-law suite with a kitchen, family room, fireplace, bedroom/bonus, and full bath with steam shower/sauna. Outside you'll find a 40x120 pole barn with four 14-foot overhead doors, 24x24 office, 12x60 RV carport with 30 & 50 amp hookups, a 5-stall horse barn with tack room, hay loft and wash bay, large equipment shed, basketball court, and endless room to enjoy country living. Whether you're looking for a private estate, horse property, hobby farm, or the ultimate recreational retreat, this one-of-a-kind Trafalgar property offers endless possibilities and is truly a rare find.

2508 W Indian Creek Road, Trafalgar
$1,399,900
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22116757 MLS
Custom-built 2022 barndominium on 31 amazing acres with a mix of wooded and open ground, certified wetlands, and private trails for hiking, ATV riding, hunting, and outdoor recreation. Spacious open floor plan with a 23' GR ceiling, gas fireplace, luxury vinyl plank flooring, granite countertops throughout, hickory soft-close cabinetry, walk-in pantry, induction cooktop with pot filler, dual convection oven/microwave, and motorized blinds. The primary suite features a walk-in closet with built-ins, double vanities, soaking tub, and tiled walk-in shower. Additional highlights include a loft, Jack-and-Jill bath, sunroom, covered rear patio, and laundry room with utility sink and folding counter. The climate-controlled 60' x 50' attached garage offers heat, A/C, 220V service, floor drains, utility sink, and space for up to 8 vehicles with room for lifts. A 40' x 60' outbuilding with a 40' x 16' lean-to includes 220V and 110V electric, water, restroom rough-in, floor drains, HVAC (thermostat connection needed), underground conduit for internet/network cabling, and an exhaust fan. Additional features include a tankless water heater, owned water softener, owned 1,000-gallon propane tank, and oversized septic system designed for future home expansion. (Be sure to pull up the Special Features List for more info!)

3448 S 475 W, Trafalgar
$1,800,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 22108600 MLS
Exceptional lakefront retreat on Lamb Lake, where breathtaking water views, timeless elegance, and unparalleled outdoor living come together. Situated on a pristine 1.48-acre waterfront lot with more than 400 feet of shoreline, this remarkable property offers everything you could desire in a luxury waterfront home. Stately all-brick exterior and inviting covered front porch set the stage for the impressive interior that awaits. Nearly 5,800 square feet of thoughtfully designed living space, ideal for entertaining and everyday enjoyment. Main level features a formal dining room, spacious living room with a double-sided fireplace, and an adjoining den/library that shares the ambiance. The open, eat-in kitchen flows seamlessly to a lakeside porch, creating the perfect setting to enjoy morning coffee. Expansive windows throughout the home flood the interior with natural light. Main-level primary suite complete with a walk-in closet and direct access to the deck. The ensuite bath features dual vanities, jetted soaking tub, and a separate tiled shower. Two additional main-level bedrooms share a Jack-and-Jill full bathroom. Finished walkout lower level expands the living space with a large family room, fourth bedroom, full bathroom, fitness area, equipment garage, and multiple storage spaces. Whether you prefer soaking up the sun or relaxing in the shade, you'll find endless opportunities to enjoy the lake. The expansive full-length composite deck, complete with a gazebo, and the covered lower-level patio provide outstanding spaces for entertaining. After a day on the water, gather around the custom outdoor fireplace and enjoy the peaceful evenings. Gently sloping, park-like yard leads to the shoreline and private dock. Unique combination of main-body lake views while offering a dock tucked into a calm cove-perfect for swimming, fishing and your boat slips. Attached 2-car and detached 3-car offer plenty of garage space for storage. Truly a one-of-a-kind waterfront estate!

7540 S Susan Lane, Trafalgar
$13,461,132
22107289 MLS
AGENTS & DEVELOPERS - this is the opportunity you've been waiting to find. Nearly 193 contiguous acres in a prime, fast growing corridor just a half mile from the State Road 135 & State Road 252 intersection in the booming Trafalgar, Indiana market. This high visibility intersection and surrounding area already features strong national brands - McDonald's, Taco Bell, Burger King, Subway, and Dairy Queen - along with well established local favorites. Indian Creek High School sits less than one mile from the property, adding tremendous appeal for future residential growth. The surrounding area features numerous residential and commercial rooftops supported by city water and city sewer. The land itself offers flat, usable acreage, entirely outside the floodplain, making it ideal for large scale development. Recreational amenities are close by, including Sweetwater Lake, Cordry Lake, Princes Lakes, and Lamb Lake, all within a 10-20 minute drive. For commuters, the location provides convenient access to major destinations: 45 minutes to Downtown Indianapolis, 45 minutes to Indianapolis International Airport, 45 minutes to Bloomington, and only 90 minutes to Louisville This is a rare, high value development tract in one of Central Indiana's most promising growth areas - the kind of opportunity that doesn't come along often.

West 400 S, Trafalgar
$1,099,000
3 Beds ⋅ 3 Baths ⋅ 22103898 MLS
Nestled along the desirable north shore of Lamb Lake, this beautifully appointed 3-bedroom waterfront retreat offers the perfect opportunity to embrace lake living just in time for summer. Situated on .77 acres, this ranch-style home with a finished walkout basement combines comfort, privacy, and effortless access to the water. The spacious main-level primary suite serves as a peaceful sanctuary, featuring a luxurious en suite bath with jetted tub, separate shower, walk-in closet, cozy sitting area, and private access to the lakeside deck - the ideal setting for morning coffee overlooking the water. A second main-level bedroom with its own en suite bath provides comfort and convenience for guests or family. At the heart of the home, the open-concept living and kitchen area is highlighted by vaulted ceilings and a striking stone fireplace, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere for gathering and entertaining. The finished walkout lower level expands the living space with a generous family room, third bedroom, bonus room, full bath, and game area. Outside, thoughtfully designed outdoor living spaces blend natural beauty with functional hardscape and landscaping. Multiple decks and patios overlook the tranquil cove, while the lower patio with hot tub creates the perfect place to unwind after a day on the water. A gentle slope leads to the private dock and pontoon lift with minimal steps, making lake access exceptionally convenient. The calm cove waters are ideal for swimming, floating, and fishing right from your dock, while the main body of the lake is only a short 2-3 minute boat ride away. Whether you're seeking a weekend escape or a year-round waterfront residence, this exceptional property offers the perfect balance of relaxation, recreation, and refined lakefront living.

7592 S Poplar Point Drive, Trafalgar
$1,050,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 22087215 MLS
Beautiful Updated Lamb Lake two-story home lakefront home with a walkout basement and private boat dock. Designed to maximize the lake views, the home features large windows and new sliding glass doors that bring in natural light and showcase the scenic surroundings. The main level includes hardwood floors, a gorgeous custom kitchen with tile flooring and granite countertops, and comfortable living spaces ideal for both everyday living and entertaining. The generous primary suite overlooks the lake and features a well-appointed bath with a soaking tub and walk-in shower, creating a relaxing retreat at the end of the day. 4 bedrooms and 3 full baths there is plenty of space for family and guests. Full bath and bedroom or office in basement and also a bonus room that would make a wonderful wine room. Outside, you'll find a boathouse, ample parking, and a four-car garage-perfect for lake toys and storage. Surrounded by wooded privacy, the property feels peaceful and secluded while still offering access to all the amenities Lamb Lake is known for, including boating, fishing, water skiing, and a private beach with a shelter house.

8191 S Bayview Court, Trafalgar
$1,250,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 22067815 MLS
Located on 500 acre Lamb Lake, this beautiful 4 bedroom/3.5 bath home has absolutely everything you need to enjoy privately or entertain friends and family. Meticulously cared for, this property offers 3 levels of usable space. Top level includes 2 bedrooms, full bathroom, recently updated kitchen with large dining area, formal sitting area with fireplace and stunning lake-side views. Middle level offers a spacious family room with soaring 20 ft ceilings and incredible natural light or choose to joy the cozy sitting area around 2nd wood burning fireplace and bar. Primary bedroom on middle level boasts a large walk in closet and access to screened in patio. Lower level has expansive bunk room, full bath and workout/gym area. This home has a screened in porch, open air porch, multiple decks/patios, the outdoor areas will cater to a multitude of wants and loves. Lakeside gazebo is a great option to warm up around the fire pit after a long day on the water. Fully landscaped property and terraced down to large private dock spanning the 150ft of shoreline with power and covered boat lift. Phenomenal water views and lake location providing plenty of space to swim, fish and sunbathe. Great storage space in and out. Decking is maintenance-free trex composite. Outdoor shower, home generator, whole house surge protection, newer tank-less water heater, wine fridge, integrated surround sound speakers; the intricate details on this property go on and on.

4465 Grouse Drive, Trafalgar
$3,075,000
5 Beds ⋅ 6 Baths ⋅ 22046491 MLS
Create family traditions in this custom-built estate set on 60.22 secluded acres, featuring a stocked 7+ acre lake complete with a fishing cabin, dock, and lighted shelter house. Car enthusiasts will appreciate the heated 60'X90' Morton building with 14' overhead door accommodating 10 or more vehicles, a separate 30'x50' heated 4+ car garage with 220 power includes a workshop, and office, while a drive-thru 3 car garage is attached to the home! Experience the best of country living with a 100'X45' horse barn with an indoor arena, four 14'X15' box stalls with hay chutes and adjustable wall divider, tack room, feed room and hay loft. Inside, exquisite craftsmanship shines throughout with 10-foot ceilings, extensive millwork, a grand foyer with sweeping staircase. The elegant country kitchen includes Nichols cabinetry, granite countertops, walk in pantry and a massive sunny eating area with gorgeous lake views. A magnificent oak fireplace is the focal point of the living room. The dining room boasts a rich wood tray ceiling. The main-level primary suite features hardwood floors, lighted tray ceiling, a spa inspire bath with dual vanities, Kohler soaking tub, tiled shower, and custom his and her closets. A well-planned back hall offers a guest suite with private bath, laundry, a custom drop zone for coats and gear, and a half bath. Upstairs the 3rd bedroom has a private bath, the 4th and 5th bedroom share a Jack and Jill bath, there is also a large sitting room with a lake view balcony, and 1,400 sq ft of unfinished attic space. The lower level features a stunning oak bar, home theater with screen and projector, rec area, full bath, plus 1200 square feet of mechanical room and storage. All levels can be accessed by a beautiful wood-paneled elevator. Modern comfort meets efficiency with dual-zoned HVAC with a closed loop geothermal system for the main floor and basement and a separate furnace and A/C for the upper level. Truly a rare find!

1099 W 375 S, Trafalgar
$1,345,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 22054479 MLS
OH MY GOODNESS! Don't MISS OUT on this RARE, GORGEOUS, PRIVATE 23+ ACRE PROPERTY in TRAFALGAR! NEARLY 5,000 sq ft CUSTOM BUILT, 4 BED, 3 1/2 BATH, 3 car GARAGE STUNNING HOME on a FULLY FINISHED WALKOUT BASEMENT! The property is even just as AMAZING as the home! TWO PARCELS (10ac & 13.36ac) - mostly wooded OASIS! As you drive in, cross a beautiful bridge & travel a winding tree-lined driveway that opens up to a COMPLETELY QUIET SANTUARY of just you and the WILDLIFE! There is room for play, raising animals, gardening, homesteading or whatever your heart desires! The back 10 acres is 1/2 hay field, 1/2 woods with a creek/walking trails. The home & barns sit on the 13+ partially wooded acres. The 30' X 48' POLE BARN has concrete floors, 14' walls, electric, 50 amp RV plug outside, two 12'x16' overhead doors; and the barn is adjacent to the open 5 ac hay field. There is an additional 20'X 40' Livestock Barn w/fenced pasture, and 20' x 20' Storage Building. ALL BRICK MIKE RAY BUILT HOME --Step up to the HUGE PORCH, open the front door and be greeted with a WARM FAMILY ROOM cozied around the wood-burning FIREPLACE, yet has open & tall ceilings providing incredible space for get-togethers. The main living area is a split floor plan giving privacy to the HUGE MASTER SUITE, stunning master bathroom with WALK-IN SHOWER, WALK-IN/THROUGH CLOSET, and laundry room. The other two bedrooms are on the opposite side of the home and share a bathroom; Central Vac, and GEOTHERMAL heating/cooling. The FULL WALKOUT BASEMENT is basically a WHOLE NEW LIVING SPACE, offering the FOURTH BEDROOM, FULL bathroom, KITCHEN, FAMILY ROOM w/YAMAHA SURROUND SOUND, and tons of FLEX SPACE. Could even be a great IN-LAWS QUARTERS. The backyard boasts a WELL-MAINTAINED above-ground POOL w/DECK, TONS of AWESOME SPACE for COOKOUTS, GAMES, & SWIM PARTIES! Back of house is plumbed for an inground pool, & bathroom. COUNTRY LIVING, yet so close to town- 7 min to school, 20 min to Franklin, 50 min to downtown Indy

2283 Indian Creek Road, Trafalgar
$1,200,000
22053772 MLS
Unlock the potential of this expansive commercial building, once home to a local school, now ready for its next chapter. Whether you're dreaming of office suites, apartments, retail spaces, restaurants, or a mixed-use development-this property offers the size and flexibility to bring your vision to life. With its solid construction, wide hallways, and multiple entry points, the layout is ideal for conversion into professional offices, boutique shops, loft-style apartments, or a vibrant commercial hub. Generous natural light, high ceilings, and plenty of parking add to the appeal, while the building's central location ensures great visibility and accessibility. If you're an investor, developer, or business owner looking for a unique opportunity-this is it. Bring your creativity and transform this former school into a thriving destination.

200 W Pearl Street, Trafalgar
$1,314,000
4 Beds ⋅ 5 Baths ⋅ 22037835 MLS
Tucked away on nearly 39 acres in the heart of Trafalgar, this property offers a rare blend of comfort, function, and country living. The 2-story brick home welcomes you with an open floor plan, abundant natural light, and a striking grand stairway leading to a loft and three spacious upstairs bedrooms. The main-level primary suite features a full bath, while the large living room showcases a full-wall brick fireplace. A chef's kitchen with a center island, custom cabinetry, and generous counter space flows beautifully to the enclosed sunroom and wood deck-perfect for enjoying peaceful countryside views. The finished, poured-wall basement provides endless possibilities with a second kitchen, recreation room, family room with fireplace, sauna, steam shower, and walk-in gun safe-ideal for in-law quarters, entertaining, or extended guest stays. Additional updates include a newer roof (6 years), dual HVAC, fresh interior paint, whole-house generator, and low-maintenance exterior. Outdoors, this property is designed for both work and play. The 40x120 barn with 16' ceilings and 14' doors includes epoxy floors, floor drains, a 24x24 heated/cooled office, showroom space, 2-post lift, RV lean-to, and separate 200-amp service. Horse enthusiasts will appreciate the 5-stall barn with hay loft, tack room, water, and electric. Additional features include a large equipment building, fully fenced pastures with vinyl and hi-tensile hot wire fencing, hay field, and wooded acreage with two creeks, deer, and turkey. A basketball court with Gorilla goal adds to the recreational appeal. This turnkey property delivers the complete package-privacy, space, and versatile amenities-all within a stunning natural setting.

2508 W Indian Creek Road, Trafalgar
$940,000
3 Beds ⋅ 2 Baths ⋅ 22031132 MLS
Beautifully updated Lamb Lake lakefront home w/over 100' lakefront & spectacular views! Gorgeous great room w/gas fireplace and plenty of room to entertain. Opens to roomy lakeside deck w/mounted TV. Spacious bright updated gourmet kitchen w/quartz counters, tile splash block, center island, & stainless steel appliances. Huge Laundry/Pantry room has wall of storage cabinets. Main level also has updated full bath and office area that could be used for more formal dining. Upper level full bath with double sinks, free standing soaking tub and walk-in shower adjoins to Primary bedroom. Private vanity in Primary bedroom. Primary bedroom and bedroom 3 both have doors opening to balcony overlooking lake. Handy golf cart path to boat dock provides easy access to the lake and includes the golf cart! Lots of dock area for enjoying lakefront, also has covered boat lift. Driveway with extra parking for boats and visitors. Wonderful home for full time or weekend getaway. Must see to appreciate all the special features. Fishing, boating, skiing, swimming, private beach w/shelter house & wifi. Your opportunity to enjoy the best of Lake Living. (See list of special features and updates)

7809 S Solitude Lane, Trafalgar
$1,215,000
22007371 MLS
Nice mix of good woods and tillable ground with all 4 parcels offered as one. Good mix of Indiana hardwoods, hills and ravines of 90 plus/minus acres of great recreational ground while about 42 acres of tillable ground (currently farmed). Still time to close prior to hunting season! The 4 parcels are not available to split due to limited road frontage of 679 ft. Tenant rights thru end of 2024. Seller will not do any surveys. You must look at the listing with an agent.

W 550 Road S, Trafalgar
$1,280,000
5 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 21959227 MLS
5 bedroom, 3.5 bath home with absolutely stunning views on Lamb Lake, located just one hour south of Indianapolis. This gorgeous lake front home boasts 240 ft of shoreline frontage. Prime location for swimming, boating, or fishing on the 500 acre private lake. Enjoy a brand new multi level composite deck and railing to sip your morning coffee or share a dinner overlooking the lake views. Take advantage of the new boat house with 2 slips and a lift. This home lends itself to entertaining and multi family stays with 2 primary ensuites, a bunk room, and 2 additional bedrooms and full bath upstairs. Main floor features kitchen with granite countertops, SS appliances, walk in pantry, dining room with lake views, great room with fireplace and tons of natural light, game room, half bath, and utility room with lots of space. Basement reveals plenty of room for lake storage, workout space, and 3 car tandem garage. Newly paved driveway for easy in and out. Don't miss out on this one of a kind setting!

7749 S Indian Ridge Drive, Trafalgar
$1,245,000
4 Beds ⋅ 4 Baths ⋅ 21946642 MLS
Gorgeous Custom 4 BR/4 Bath home at LAMB LAKE on Private CuldeSac. Home has completely been updated/remodeled with luxury contemporary finishes in 2021, New Landscape lighting , 3 car Garage w/epoxy floors finished & 40'x28' SF of Rec, Exercise, and/or office space above garage in 2023. Hardwood floors, Gourmet Kitchen w oversized kitchen island, quartz counters, custom cabinets, built ins. Fin Walkout LL with 2 bedrooms / 2 baths and large storage room, Family Room w/ Gas Stone Fireplace. Wet bar located in basement great for hosting and packing for a day on the lake. Sunroom & Windows Galore overlooking Prominent location in a wide cove with amazing panoramic views of Lake.180' Shoreline. Newer Dock w/Sundeck & Boat lift & extra slip!

4520 W Jurist Court, Trafalgar

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.