Refine Search
Sort by
$505,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 22123372 MLS
STUNNING, RARE NEARLY 5-ACRE PROPERTY in INDIAN CREEK SCHOOLS northeast of Trafalgar! As you pull into the manicured entrance to the blacktop driveway, you will be in AWE of the rolling BEAUTY dotted with so MANY MATURE TREES as you travel down the long drive to this ultimate PRIVATE SLICE OF HEAVEN. You will hear nothing but wildlife and the neighbor's donkey or horses, from time-to-time. The property sits on 3 SEPARATE PARCELS! There is a CREEK! Plenty of great space to fence HORSES, CATTLE or any of your animals! There are 2 small outbuildings. One building has potential for small livestock. This COZY home feels like your own private SANCTUARY. The whole south side of the house is full of windows for the best views. One of the sellers' favorite things is that it is so private, they love being able to leave their windows open most days! These are the ORIGINAL OWNERS, so lots of pride in ownership here! This CUSTOM-BUILT 3 bedroom, 2 1/2 bath home boasts MANY UPDATES: Kitchen updated in 2022 with beautiful quartz countertops, painted maple cabinets w/soft close drawers; ceramic tile backsplash and luxury vinyl flooring; NEW home exterior paint (front in 2024, sides and back 2026); new electrical panel 2026; new garage doors 2025; new Jeld-wen windows (except kitchen), front door, fiber cement siding and gutters 2005. Hardwood flooring throughout the main level. The master suite is HUGE with walk-in closets and beautiful built in shelving. The 2-car garage is little oversized with a great little workbench area. The 16'x15' covered concrete patio is a great spot for your morning coffee, evening tea or grilling area with views for days! 10 minutes to Franklin, 7 minutes to IC Schools, 45 minutes to INDY. Showings start Friday, September 4 @9AM.

3113 S 25 W, Trafalgar

$425,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 22110437 MLS
Escape to the peace and privacy of country living with this charming farmhouse situated on 5 beautiful acres in Trafalgar. Surrounded by mature trees and open green space, this property offers the perfect blend of rural charm, functionality, and room to grow. Inside you'll find 3 bedrooms plus a fourth sleeping area, 2 full bathrooms, and a warm, inviting layout that's ready to make your own. Whether you're looking for extra space for guests, a home office, or a hobby room, this flexible floor plan has you covered. Outside is where this property truly shines. The impressive 48' x 48' pole barn with electricity is complemented by an attached 16' x 32' garage and dedicated hot tub room, creating endless possibilities for a workshop, business, storage, or recreational space. A 30-amp RV hookup located near the barn makes it easy to accommodate campers or visiting guests. The property also features an old pasture, providing opportunities for hobby farming, horses, livestock, or simply enjoying wide-open country views. The sprawling acreage is surrounded by mature trees, offering exceptional privacy while still providing plenty of open space to enjoy the outdoors. Conveniently located just minutes from Trafalgar with easy access to Franklin, Greenwood, and Indianapolis, this property offers the perfect combination of peaceful country living and everyday convenience. If you've been dreaming of acreage, a functional outbuilding with electricity, and endless possibilities, this is the property you've been waiting for. Schedule your private showing today!

6442 S 300 W, Trafalgar

$435,000
4 Beds 3 Baths 22101051 MLS
Step right up, folks, and feast your eyes on 809 W Pearl ST in TRAFALGAR, IN! This delightful single-family residence, built in 1994, offers a generous 2344 square feet of pure fun and frolic. It's not just a house; it's a launchpad for your most playful dreams! Peaceful evenings on your wrap around porch or quiet evenings in your sunroom, makes this home a perfect match for everyone. With four charming bedrooms, there's ample space for everyone to spread out, build epic pillow forts, or simply enjoy a quiet snooze. The two full bathrooms are ready for all your bubble bath adventures, while the convenient half bathroom ensures no one is ever left waiting. Beautifully updated kitchen, easy for entertaining. Spanning two delightful stories, this home is practically begging for a game of hide-and-seek. And with a sprawling 17729 square foot lot, your outdoor escapades are limited only by your imagination! Think epic garden parties, spirited games of tag, smores over the bonfire or perhaps even a future bocce ball court. Fresh paint and flooring throughout. Newer mechanicals and majority of all new windows. Ready for a lifetime of joyful memories? Come discover the playful possibilities at this Trafalgar treasure!

809 W Pearl Street, Trafalgar

$430,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 22098423 MLS
Beautiful Brown County ranch home with a panoramic view on 5 Acres and has 2 ponds! This home has an open concept & 3 bedroom with a Walk-out basement. Vaulted ceilings open this home to the living room, kitchen & dining and offer tons of windows for great views, lots of natural light and beautiful hardwood floors. Kitchen features lots of counter space, cabinets, center island, gas oven/range, dishwasher & refrigerator. Primary suite has big walk-in closet, garden tub & access to screened in porch & deck. NEW CARPET in all bedrooms. Basement is semi-finished and ready for your creations (Pre-wired and plumbed for 2nd kitchen or wet bar and bathroom stool plumbed with ejector pit )! There is also room for a shop on the other side of the basement & has lots of lighting & 220 outlet. The 46x34 garage fits 6+ cars & workshop and has a separate 100 amp service, foam insulation walls and ceiling all set up for a hobbyist... Then take a stroll through the woods on your path leading to your 2 PONDS. Extra living space in walkout basement just needs paint & flooring to be finished (extra drywall included). This space could be your 2nd living space or In-Law Qtrs, plus more storage. Home is on county water & septic. The 2 ponds have shared ownership. Water heater newer. Propane tank rented (Suburban Propane $51.36/year rental)

2830 Webber Hill Road, Trafalgar

$465,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 22074409 MLS
Begin Your Homesteading Lifestyle! Discover peaceful country living on 2 acres of open land, ready for your gardens, animals, and self-sufficient dreams. The charming farmhouse features 2 bedrooms and 1.5 baths, completely rebuilt from the studs in 2014, blending modern comfort with timeless appeal. Plumbing and electrical as well. A spacious 30x40 barn with 12-foot and 10-foot garage doors offers endless possibilities for equipment, animals, or workshop space. The oversized 3-car garage provides plenty of room for tinkering, hobbies, or storage - and includes a fully equipped 1-bedroom apartment above, perfect for multigenerational living, guest quarters, or rental income potential. Whether you're seeking a peaceful retreat or a productive homestead, this property offers the best of both worlds - privacy, functionality, and room to grow. 2014 interior taken down to studs. wiring, plumbing, electrical box

7641 S 500 W, Trafalgar

$484,754
4 Beds 3 Baths 22072172 MLS
The Cooper offers many features including a large foyer, a wide turned staircase and a very open concept first floor- you won't be disappointed with this beautiful new construction home. This home is designed to fit you and your family's needs, starting with a three car garage includes storage for you to work on your next project or to store any equipment you have. Never miss out when you entertain in the open concept first floor. Your great room is spacious enough to host game nights and the dining nook gives you a spot to enjoy family meals or help divide between your great room and kitchen. The kitchen space is extremely versatile. Featuring a large walk-in pantry, spacious cabinets for storage, and the largest H-Frame kitchen island of any of Arbor's plans. The Sunroom off the kitchen gives a little extra living space. Moving up the stairs, you are met with a large loft with enough room to add a couch for relaxing on and a second floor laundry room. Each bedroom comes with a large walk-in closet so you'll never run out of storage space! If you are looking for your perfect oasis- look no further than the primary suite. A spacious primary bedroom with his and hers closets and and a walk in tile shower.

333 Geralyn Drive, Trafalgar

$450,000
2 Beds 1 Baths 22067835 MLS
This charming 2-bedroom, 1-bath home is perfectly situated on 7.16 acres, offering a serene country lifestyle with modern comforts. A tranquil pond, a versatile horse barn, and a spacious 2-car garage complete this exceptional property. Home features: Inviting living room: Cozy and bright, with a fireplace, this is the perfect space for relaxing or entertaining guests. Kitchen with dining area: A functional dining space, ideal for family meals and conversation. Sunroom: Enjoy your morning coffee or read a book while in the peaceful sunroom looking through a large window. Full basement: Provides ample storage space or offers a blank canvas for future expansion. Horse barn: The 5-stall horse barn is an equestrians dream offering a well-equipped barn that provides plenty of space for horses and includes a tack room, wash stall, water, electric, and water access in the near pasture so you don't have to haul water. Outdoor highlights: Private pond: A picturesque pond, stocked with bass and bluegill, offers a calm setting for enjoying nature right in your backyard. Detached 2-car garage: This car enthusiasts dream offers secure parking, car lift, heat, AC, and additional storage or workshop space. Extra shed: An additional outbuilding provides extra storage for equipment, tools, or farm supplies. 7.16 acres: The large, lot provides endless opportunities for outdoor hobbies, gardening, or expansion. This property is a rare find. Schedule your appointment today and be one step closer to enjoying comfortable country living.

2750 W 750 S, Trafalgar

$480,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 22068997 MLS
Wonderful opportunity to purchase on 500-acre Lamb Lake. Sitting on almost an acre, this ranch home with finished walk out basement is nestled in a beautiful wooded setting. Home is located off the water, but all lake rights are included and can be enjoyed. Home structure is a wonderful mixture of natural stone and wood exterior with private backyard and multi-level decks offering plenty of area to entertain. Open living room with natural stone fireplace leading into dining and large kitchen with Nichols cabinets. Open basement with 2nd natural stone fireplace, 2 bonus rooms currently used as 2nd and 3rd bedrooms, or could be office and gym. Level driveway with extra gravel area to park & 10x10 workshop in garage. Exterior painted and new gutters in '22. Fresh paint on both decks and glassed-in porch. Hard wood flooring on main level, carpet in master, LVT flooring throughout walk out basement & upper level fully enclosed glass porch installed in '22. Recently updated stone bathroom countertops. Incredible price point for Lamb Lake community where you can enjoy long days on the water enjoying water sports, fishing, or anchoring in coves to enjoy crystal clear water. Close proximity to hiking trails and community activities all year long. 45 min to the airport or downtown Indy, 30 min to Greenwood or Columbus and just 20 mins to historic Nashville and Brown county state park.

8048 S Indian Ridge Drive, Trafalgar

$400,000
2 Beds 2 Baths 22052384 MLS
This charming 2-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home sits on nearly 4 acres of partially wooded property in Trafalgar, offering the perfect blend of comfort and country living. The spacious interior features beautiful hardwood floors and built-ins throughout, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere in every room. The recently remodeled kitchen is a true highlight, showcasing butcher block countertops, newer stainless steel appliances, and modern updates that make cooking and entertaining a pleasure. The home includes a bonus room currently being used as a third bedroom, plus a versatile office and game room for additional living space. Step outside to enjoy the large back deck, perfect for relaxing or hosting gatherings while taking in the peaceful surroundings. The property offers exceptional outdoor amenities with four outbuildings providing ample storage and workshop space. The partially fenced pasture area is ideal for livestock or pets with plenty of room to grow. Recent improvements include a newer roof, updated windows, and quality appliances, ensuring move-in readiness and long-term value. The partially wooded acreage provides privacy and natural beauty while maintaining open pasture areas. This property combines rural tranquility with convenient access to local amenities. Whether you're looking for a peaceful retreat, hobby farm potential, or simply want more space to spread out, this well-maintained home offers the lifestyle you're seeking. The combination of modern updates, versatile living spaces, and extensive outdoor features makes this a rare opportunity in today's market.

2613 W 550 S, Trafalgar

$445,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 22047412 MLS
Nestled at 2868 S 525 W in Charming Trafalgar, this Ranch Home in Johnson County *ON 9.33 ACRES* Offers a Unique Opportunity to Embrace a Comfortable Lifestyle in a Serene Setting! Features: 3 BEDROOMS + 2 FULL BATH ~ 1,256 Sq. Ft. ~ Formal LIVING ROOM w/Lots of Natural Light; GREAT ROOM featuring a Wood-Burning Fireplace that serves as a Warm Focal Point, complemented by a Wood Wall, Beamed Ceiling, & Crown Molding that adds Character & Depth; EAT-IN KITCHEN offers a Modern Touch with Shaker Cabinets (Ample Cabinet Space!) & Tile Backsplash, blending Functionality with Stylish Design + Stainless-Steel Appliances, Pantry, & Can Lighting - & the Perfect Breakfast/Dining Area; Convenient Laundry Closet w/Cabinets; Large PRIMARY BEDROOM w/Full Shower; 2 Additional Nice-Size Bedrooms; EXTERIOR: Awesome Screened-In Porch Invites You to Relax & Enjoy the Surroundings in this Tranquil Retreat, while a Deck Provides an Ideal Space for Gatherings! Property Includes Two .25 Acre Ponds + Huge Barn w/Paddock Area~ The Property's Rural Area Location and Woods View offer a Peaceful, Private Setting that is Hard to Find!

2868 S 525 W, Trafalgar

$398,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 22033716 MLS
Don't MISS this ADORABLE, RARE, METICULOUSLY-MAINTAINED 4 BEDROOM, 2 BATH home on 1.12 ACRES in TRAFALGAR and INDIAN CREEK SCHOOLS! 3 CAR DETACHED GARAGE, WORKSHOP, and add'l STORAGE BUILDINGS. Newer HARDY PLANK SIDING, PAVED driveway, NEWER ROOF, NEW windows, NEW septic fingers, NEW HVAC. Manicured lawn and landscape. ORIGINAL WOOD FLOORS in formal living room and upstairs (under carpet), MASTER Bedroom on the MAIN LEVEL; totally RENOVATED MASTER BATHROOM. CUSTOM kitchen CABINETS. Beautiful high-end wood-looking ceramic tile in kitchen, dining and laundry room. Watch the SUNRISE while drinking your morning coffee on the HUGE BACK DECK. VIEWS are peaceful and breathtaking... PURE COUNTRY! Garden already has established strawberries, rhubarb AND plenty of room to add your own. Original home built in 1916, and back family room and laundry/mud room area were added in 1980. OUTBUILDINGS INCLUDE: CAR GARAGE is 24'x42' w/concrete floor; 20'x15' BARN w/floor and workshop; 20'x10' storage shed; 20'x14'x10' canopy. City water and sewer at the road. Easy access to SR 135, 13 minutes to Franklin, 40 minutes to downtown Indy, 30 minutes to Nashville. SHOWINGS OPEN UP AT NOON ON FRIDAY, MAY 2nd

403 N Red Gold Drive, Trafalgar

$477,000
3 Beds 2 Baths 22026017 MLS
Just in time for summer! Charming Lamb Lake retreat nestled on almost one acre wooded lot with full lake privileges to enjoy all that 500 acre Lamb Lake Association has to offer - swimming, boating, water-skiing, bass fishing, private beach, hiking and diverse wildlife. This 3 bedroom, 2 full bath home has two fireplaces and a large kitchen open to the family room with views of the quiet, private wooded yard. Gorgeous rustic wood beams throughout multiple rooms. Home has multiple decks to enjoy the wildlife and serenity. Oversized fully finished/insulated, heated and air conditioned garage and workshop give space for all hobbies and lake activities. Newer Generac and gutter guards. Maintenance free boat dock can be rented from association based on availability.

8172 S Shoreview Drive, Trafalgar

$439,900
4 Beds 3 Baths 22021611 MLS
Extremely well maintained home located on 2.05 acres in the sought after Indian Creek school District. This beautiful 4bed 3 bath home offers 2300 square-ft ot of living space along with a large two car garage. Two master suites (one on each level) which each include a full bath and walk-in closets, along with the other 2 bedrooms on the main floor with walk-in closets for plenty of storage to appreciate. The Mitsubishi dual heat pump system which is green energy certified with mini splits located in two car, garage and in the upstairs of the home was installed 2024. All new engineered hardwood flooring in the bedrooms and paint completed within the last couple years. Enjoy the peace and tranquility outdoors surrounded by beautiful, mature trees along with all the extra storage in the two oversized mini barns. The open concept of the kitchen and dining offers plenty of room for a extra large dining table along with the amazing Kitchen island and plenty of counter space. All stainless steel appliances are included along with the washer and dryer and garage refrigerator.

1039 W 550 S, Trafalgar

$450,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 22000283 MLS
NEARLY 3 ACRES- BEAUTIFUL 4B 2B PROPERTY IN TRAFALGAR WITH GREAT SCHOOLS! Are you looking to get out of the city but not be too far from the conveniences? Country living at its best, within 30 minutes of Nashville, Greenwood, Franklin, and Edinburgh. This charming brick RANCH- ONE LEVEL is set on nearly three acres and features four SPACIOUS BEDROOMS, two bathrooms and and a LARGE POLE BARN to store all of your extra belongings.Don't miss the party area behind the pole barn overlooking the beautiful woods. Inside home , you'll find two separate living areas, an updated kitchen, and four large bedrooms. Enjoy cozy evenings around the wood-burning fireplace or start your mornings on the front porch with a cup of coffee. The yard has an underground electric fence for your furry friends! This home is ready for you to enjoy! SELLERS ARE WILLING TO PAY UP TO $5,000 IN BUYERS CLOSING COSTS OR BUY DOWN!- Back On Market! No fault of house or sellers!

618 W 750 S, Trafalgar

$480,000
5 Beds 3 Baths 22002429 MLS
Don't miss out, properties like this are hard to come by in Trafalgar and this home has it all! Peaceful country living is yours, with two full acres, an in-ground pool, and garage storage for the whole family, what more could you want? Gather family and friends in your spacious living room with vaulted ceilings OR entertain out by the pool. Space to spread out and enjoy your home doesn't end there. With 5 bedrooms and 3 bathrooms you'll have a room for every need. Buyers will love, among many things, updated home and pool mechanicals, outdoor bar updated this month, not one but TWO wood burning fireplaces for cozy nights, and a private and tranquil front pond to enjoy year round. Ready to call this property home? Schedule a showing this weekend so you can see the beauty of this property firsthand.

6732 S 25 W, Trafalgar

$475,000
21997565 MLS
Great opportunity for a New Church or Church Plant to occupy a move-in ready facility! This Church is currently set up to facilitate a service with approximately 100 members in the sanctuary. Plenty of room for expansion as the building sits on a 3 acre parcel. If the property is to be used for any other purpose than a Church a variance will be needed, but there are many real possibilities. The property is currently zoned residential and could be converted to a single family residence with potential to build 2 additional residences. Possibility for "Change of Use" to commercial zoning. Pending approval, possibilities are endless: Day Care, Fitness Center, Doctor's Office, Dog Groomer, Real Estate Office, Food Pantry, Community Outreach Organization and more.

335 Pleasant Street, Trafalgar

$475,000
2 Baths 21997470 MLS
Great opportunity for a New Church or Church Plant to occupy a move-in ready facility! This Church is currently set up to facilitate a service with approximately 100 members in the sanctuary. Plenty of room for expansion as the building sits on a 3 acre parcel. If the property is to be used for any other purpose than a Church a variance will be needed, but there are many real possibilities. The property is currently zoned residential and could be converted to a single family residence with potential to build 2 additional residences. Possibility for "Change of Use" to commercial zoning. Pending approval, possibilities are endless: Day Care, Fitness Center, Doctor's Office, Dog Groomer, Real Estate Office, Food Pantry, Community Outreach Organization and more.

335 Pleasant Street, Trafalgar

$450,000
4 Beds 2 Baths 21991710 MLS
Imagine yourself in the middle of woods surrounded by a beautiful lake and majestic trees . This unique property is LAKE FRONT spreading out over 3 lots giving you equisite privacy. Home includes 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, full basement, newly custom renovated kitchen, upper and lower wrap around decking, your private boat dock , pontoon , kayaks, and 2 johnboats are included. Relax at the dock, swim in the clean aerated waters, troll across the lake, fish, kayak, or just catch some sunshine. Roof replaced in 2023 with new underlayment, aluminum overhang new 2019, hard surface countertops, french doors in living room, cement hardy board siding installed 2019, insulated sunroom with a pellet stove, 3 electrical panels, windows 2008, new lennox water heater, air filter for furnace, REMC fiber internet installed with buried electrical. This property will not last long! Come make it your forever home or your family getaway!

1611 W Peoga Lake Drive, Trafalgar

$467,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21952635 MLS
Beautiful custom built Robert Lane home. All brick 3 bedroom 2.5 baths with covered side patio as well as large back patio to sit and relax while taking in the serene sites of rural living along with eagles occasionally soaring above. Seller added a 30 x 40 Pole Barn with concrete floor and electricity in 2018 as well as whole house Generac generator (2020). Home also has Leaf Filter gutter protection installed in 2021, updated windows, garage door, and in 2023 new Heat Pump and Air Handler installed. Inside, you will find gleaming hardwood flooring in most rooms. Winter months will be cozy relaxing by the woodburning fireplace in the Great Room. Kitchen cabinets have the custom rollout shelving to add to your convenience. Formal dining room could easily be office space or kids playroom. Primary bedroom bathroom has walk in shower as well as separate tub with large walk in closet. This home also has beautiful vaulted and tray ceilings to add to the elegance and charm.

4310 S 25 W, Trafalgar

$425,000
3 Beds 3 Baths 21922129 MLS
Rare Opportunity To Own A Newly Remodeled Full Brick Home With Finished Walk Out Basement! Large 1+ Acre Wooded Lot. One Level Home With Fully Finished Walkout Lower Level. This 3 Bedroom, 2.5 Bath Features an Open Concept On Both Levels Making This Home Great For Hosting & ENJOYING all that Lamb Lake has to offer. Whether You Are Looking For A Full- Time Residence Or A Weekend Home This Home Checks All The Boxes For Low Maintenance Living! White, Bright and Airy Is A Perfect Description Of This Minimalistic Home! Home has just been through EXTENSIVE remodel. All new Kitchen, Baths, Walls removed to Open Up, New Paint In & Out, New Lighting, Flooring, all New Doors & Trim, New Appliances & Counters!

7764 S Indian Ridge Drive, Trafalgar

Information Deemed Reliable But Not Guaranteed. © 2026 MIBOR Broker Listing Cooperative

Based on information submitted to the MLS GRID as of . All data is obtained from various sources and may not have been verified by broker of MLS GRID. Supplied Open House Information is subject to change without notice. All information should be independently reviewed and verified for accuracy. Properties may or may not be listed by the office/agent presenting the information. Some listings have been excluded from this website.